Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by schoen on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:02PM
(#10462074)
Hi VonGuard,
> and considered fair use
The 1201 exemption process doesn't adjudicate whether things are fair use in a way that's binding on courts, although the Copyright Office does believe that it has to express some opinion about that the uses it approves are noninfringing. But a court doesn't have to agree with that substantive question: if someone sued you for running the server they could argue that it's not a fair use, and the court that they sue you in isn't bound to agree that the Copyright Office was right to view it as noninfringing (or that this is true in the particular circumstances).
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by VonGuard on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @10:11PM
(#10462492)
Thanks for the clarification Schoen.
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by jxcl on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @06:54PM
(#10461770)
> This does not mean these titles can be redistributed, only that they can be modified for the sake of preservation.
But once the copyright expires on the disks, they may then be redistributed?
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by VonGuard on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:01PM
(#10461801)
Then they would enter public domain. Copyright, however, lasts a very, very long time. Longer than the history of computing.
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by gknoy on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:43PM
(#10461994)
It sounds like archivists could image the disks and transport those across mediums, in the interest of archival, as long as they didn't distribute them, though. Am I mistaken?
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by VonGuard on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:11PM
(#10462113)
You are correct. We can now do just about anything we want short of redistribution or commercialization.
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by jellicle on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:44PM
(#10461997)
Nearly nothing has entered the public domain in the U.S. in decades, and likely nearly nothing ever will again.
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by VonGuard on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:12PM
(#10462117)
There was that time in the 70's when you had to re-up your Copyright, and a lot of stuff fell out, like Night of the Living Dead.
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by wtallis on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:09PM
(#10462307)
Night of the Living Dead failed to ever have copyright protection due to lack of a copyright notice or registration, not from a need for renewal. Renewal became automatic in 1964, and registration or notice became optional in 1989. (And in 1976 it became possible to register for up to 5 years after publication, to allow for fixing mistakes like with Night of the Living Dead.)
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by PeterisP on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @09:04AM
(#10464154)
Theoretically yes, but I don't really expect to see copyright on any, even the oldest, software expiring during my lifetime.
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by xg15 on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @06:06AM
(#10463561)
If I understood the ruling correctly, all exemptions are technically only binding for three years, after which they have to be renewed. So in the (hopefully) hypothetical case that the librarian would not renew the excemption for archives, would that make all exibits stored on grounds of the exemption suddenly illegal? If yes, this doesn't seem like a very practical solution to me.
Re:EFF Wins Petition to Inspect and Modify Car Software
by Shish2k on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:17PM
(#10465853)
I get that MMOs are very different to regular games, but I wonder how that applies in this context - why would an MMO company strongly object to their abandonware being revived while a regular multiplayer company tolerates it?
Second, museums and archives are now permitted to circumvent copy protection in the pursuit of preservation. This means that huge stores of old games that are otherwise unavailable are now legally preservable by institutions like Stanford, The Museum of Art and Digital Entertainment, and Archive.org. Of note is the fact that the Atari ST catalog of software was preserved on pirate disks, and we've yet to find any other way to save some of those pieces of software, aside from just preserving the pirate disks. This does not mean these titles can be redistributed, only that they can be modified for the sake of preservation.
Additionally, this means museums can preserve devices that circumvent copy protection, such as floppy-to-SNES devices, which we have a few of at the MADE. Modded XBoxes can now also be preserved in an institution.
The bits that help museums means a great deal for preservation of digital assets as a whole. This was a lot of work to get done, so a huge thanks goes out to the EFF, Stanford, MIT, Harvard and Archive.org for all their hard work to get this done!