Re:Apple unlock: Judge compares request to execution order
by goffley3 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:47AM
(#10457918)
It's hard to believe something like this wouldn't fall under the fourth or fifth amendment.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Apple unlock: Judge compares request to execution order
by otterley on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @10:06AM
(#10458036)
The Government already has a warrant; so the Fourth Amendment is satisfied. The question in this case is whether the Government can compel Apple to help them execute the warrant.
Re:Apple unlock: Judge compares request to execution order
by rtpg on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @10:06AM
(#10458037)
There's some interesting case law around locked things. One train of thought is that the govt can force you to give the key to a safe, but can't force you to give the combination to a safe.
The Apple extension would be that the govt can force unlocking by Apple (since they have a key) but not by you. All the more you reason to make it technically impossible ...
Re:Apple unlock: Judge compares request to execution order
by sbov on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:24PM
(#10459081)
Do they have a key? I thought the point of the recent iPhone encryption is that they don't have a key?
Re:Apple unlock: Judge compares request to execution order
by rtpg on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:55PM
(#10462046)
In the case mentioned, the phone was running an older version of iOS where they could, in fact, unlock the phone.
But the recent ones make it impossible, yeah
Re:Apple unlock: Judge compares request to execution order
by nickodell on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:57AM
(#10457975)
The fifth amendment doesn't apply. This isn't self-incrimination.
As to whether the fourth amendment applies - that's the question they're answering in court. Is this a search, in which case the government can compel Apple to disclose useful information, or is the DoJ asking for Apple to do something on their behalf?