News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can you be added to a watchlist for playing a video game? by bediger4000 on Monday October 26, 2015 @04:34PM (#10454273)
there is an incentive to keep watchlists small, focused, and accurate

I think there is no incentive to keep watch lists small or focused or accurate. In fact, there's a huge disincentive for that. If some name (or other identifying info) gets on a watch list, and then someone makes a judgement call to take that name/info off the list, and then the person identified by that name or info does something violent and/or stupid, whichever agency the judgement caller works for, and the call him/herself would come under enormous, very unpleasant scrutiny. The 9/11 thing about "failing to connect the dots" almost certainly weighs heavily on every one connected with watch lists.

There's zero incentive for any outsider to call for a name or other info removal for exactly the same reason. What if...? becomes the single overriding concern.

Re:Can you be added to a watchlist for playing a video game? by Laaw on Monday October 26, 2015 @05:01PM (#10454448)
There's no value in a tag if it doesn't mean anything, and if membership on a watchlist is merely another way of saying "this person played a video game once", then analysts are going to discount membership to the watchlist.
Re:Can you be added to a watchlist for playing a video game? by bediger4000 on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:04PM (#10455796)
The lists probably have no value to the analysts anyway. As you note, names/ID info are put on the list by numbskulls, not for any good reason.

The reason the lists exist is to cover FBI and DHS bureaucratic ass if some long shot "terrorism" event happens - "Hey, they were on the watchlist - we connected those dots!"