The first company may do better on margins per sale, but the second will have better quality/productivity per employee.
1. If a company is paying above-market wages, then by definition there are more people who want to work there than there are available spots, so the second company will get some of the overflow.
2. The market for a particular kind of labor (e.g. phone techs) is usually much larger than whatever market for outputs these two companies are involved in (e.g., credit-card processing), so one company paying above-market wages is unlikely to change the market wage level very much.
This could definitely break down for some very specialized jobs.
It actually appears more likely that employers have on average already set wages slightly above the market-clearing level in order to improve productivity and maximize profits. This is the theory of "efficiency wages" [1], which tries to explain why unemployment persists when companies could cut wages and employ more people.
There is no free lunch.
[1] http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/04/the...
Of course, in that idealized world, there are no "excess profits" (profits not commensurable with risk), so it should be impossible for the company to raise wages like that anyway.
So the real question is: why is this company so profitable, and can that continue indefinitely? Or does this guy just have such a high tolerance for risk that "acceptable profits" for him are unacceptable for any possible competitors?