Re:The False Trade-Off Between Security and Liberty
by AnimalMuppet on Monday October 26, 2015 @01:14PM
(#10452782)
If I understand this correctly, the claim is that the massive surveillance is preventing deep, complicated plots like 9/11, so that what we get instead are more situations where one person does a (somewhat) mass shooting. It's not "mass" on the scale of 9/11, though - not even all of them put together are. So in terms of people's lives, it's a net win.
And in terms of freedom to just get on with your life, it's a net win for most of us... so far.
The problem is, if you give the government enough power to spy on people in order to prevent terrorism, sooner or later someone might use it for other than the intended purpose. And here the article's argument works exactly: You don't know how much tyranny has been prevented by denying the government the power to spy on citizens.
And in terms of freedom to just get on with your life, it's a net win for most of us... so far.
The problem is, if you give the government enough power to spy on people in order to prevent terrorism, sooner or later someone might use it for other than the intended purpose. And here the article's argument works exactly: You don't know how much tyranny has been prevented by denying the government the power to spy on citizens.