Not that I totally disagree, but, signing up for Slack is easier than using NickServ for the average person. There's a bunch of features that make HipChat, Slack, Hall et al easier to use than IRC, especially for someone who doesn't want to learn anything new.
Just worth thinking about...
In general I agree that ease-of-use is a big factor. Having said that, I was witness to decidedly non-technical teens in a mid-size town quite happily using mIRC in 2004, so maybe we're not giving people quite enough credit. If you tell people something is hard to use they'll believe you.
The real lesson is to look into what has been done and worked before and see how it can be improved if you're looking for "new" ideas and businesses.
In contrast, I've never even heard of all the things mentioned above.
The easy of use of bots and flooding scripts was a downside, not an advantage.
Any web page that embedded IRC had to deal with that nonsense.
It's a social question. The most the tech did wrong was not making flooding impossible in the first place.
I read an article about Slack that praised their speed of integrating feedback and iterating with the following example: "the Slack team quickly identified small changes that had a big impact: Within the list of channels, they added fields for a description and the number of people using that channel."