> But we should consider the counterfactual. What if Allende had stayed in power? Chile would not be the beacon of stability and growth that it is today.
Excuse me, but this is utter bullshit. We don't know what would happen. I was born in communist country (Czechoslovakia), and in the 1970s and 1980s (and in fact overall), it was much more civilized than Pinochet's regime. Maybe we had slower GDP growth (probably not by much, Pinochet economic policies were no super success either); so what? Higher GDP growth, in my book, doesn't justify killing a single dissident (because, "considering the counter factual", there are plenty examples of having high growth without violence).
> Membership in the euroclub requires fiscal responsibility; governments can no longer rely on running the print presses to pay their debt.
Weirdly, in the U.S., rules like that apparently do not hold. California didn't have fiscal responsibility and is still a member of the club, and FED not running a printing press?
Like ok, we get it, the US is your country, and you can completely fuck up your own republic and turn it into a surveilled and controlled human zoo dedicated to the worship of mammon. But stop going and fucking everyone else's country.
On a personal note, I can only wish that the US had intervened more successfully against Castro in Cuba, the home that my family and millions of others have fled to America from.
How about the people who actually live there? I get that sometimes the people of a country can be helpless against an oppressor and need foreign aid, but people in Chile actually voted for Allende. It's not the same as Cuba.
The people who voted for Allende didn't think so, and they won that election somehow.
>The issue of Allende wanting to turn Chile into a Soviet satellite state just like Cuba.
How is getting the guy killed going to make people less likely to want to ally with either the actual Soviets or with what the Soviets stood for? Look at Chavez's paranoia for an example.
>Unfortunately, there's not always morally pure option and you have to practice realpolitik.
How about this piece of realpolitik: Don't fuck up other people's democratic governments if you don't want a huge loss of reputation, moral authority and political capital.
Don't just do something! Stand there!
Yes. 36.6% of the population voted for him, while a combined 63.4% voted for candidates from the conservative parties. As President, Allende flat out ignored thousands of court rulings and congressional actions. The Chilean Congress itself passed a resolution calling for his ouster, by military or other means.
If it didn't have international consequences, I'd agree with you that people should be allowed to elect politicians that will run their country into the ground. But preventing any further Soviet expansion into the Western hemisphere was imperative for the US at the time.
The choices weren't just between Allende or Not Allende. Every candidate had their fair chance, and if winning with 36.6% of the votes sounds odd to you, it's probably because you are accustomed to the two-party system, which has its own advantages and disadvantages.
>If it didn't have international consequences, I'd agree with you that people should be allowed to elect politicians that will run their country into the ground
So people are free to choose their own politicians only as long as they live somewhere that is literally inconsequential in the international stage?
As soon as their country gets relevant, their choices will have "international consequences" after all and they will have to ally themselves with the biggest super power one way or another. And god forbid they choose the wrong super power.
How's that again?
I think JFK captured the guiding principles best:
Sometimes it's led to difficult and morally dubious decisions, like US support for Pinochet's coup against Allende in Chile. But we should consider the counterfactual. What if Allende had stayed in power? Chile would not be the beacon of stability and growth that it is today. Based on Allende's relationships with Castro and the Soviet Union, it would probably be a lot like Castro's Cuba, a society totally hollowed out by communism.As an aside, the characterization of the situation in Greece is completely inaccurate too. Membership in the euroclub requires fiscal responsibility; governments can no longer rely on running the print presses to pay their debt. Greece continued to waste money it did not have, and was refusing the demands for budget discipline from the countries that were keeping it afloat.