News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Era of Black Boxes by jacquesm on Monday January 11, 2010 @06:45AM (#1044881)
What a super piece of writing. The 'phones on the hook can be used to eavesdrop' is fairly well known, but the main point of the article I think is that you no longer stand a chance to figure out what is going on in consumer electronics.

When I was a kid I'd make a bit of money repairing TVs by cannibalizing a few other 'corpses', such an endeavor would be nearly impossible today.

I fixed a computer a few weeks ago, the motherboard was put together with el-cheapo capacitors that had all blown their tops until there wasn't enough of them left to stabilize the circuitry they were in.

Easy enough you'd think. What would have taken 5 minutes in the pre-smd time took me a couple of hours and it was still sub-standard work.

Now I've been 'out' of electronics for a long time, almost 30 years now, but in a way I'm really happy. I'd hate to be an electronics hobbyist today, the state of the art has advanced so far that you're probably best off buying an FPGA kit and using that instead of rolling your own circuitry.

Arduino seems to capitalize on that feeling, to allow people to take a small step back from those black boxes and to open them up again.

Re:The Era of Black Boxes by aristus on Monday January 11, 2010 @01:31PM (#1045628)
One thing that disturbs me is how incurious people seem to be about their hardware. I was talking with two people who make their entire living from iPhone apps, and they didn't know it is an ARM device.

Part of it is surface-mount components, part of it is that the hardware is being pushed down the commodity stack. But I wonder what kitchen innovations we are missing because few people tinker with the bare metal anymore.

For 30-odd years hackers built their own lightsabers. Now they've pretty much stopped. I can't decide if that's inevitable or not.

Re:The Era of Black Boxes by pyre on Monday January 11, 2010 @03:47PM (#1045948)
To some extent things are technology-limited now. Not many people are going to build a 45nm process in their garage.
Re:The Era of Black Boxes by aristus on Monday January 11, 2010 @06:18PM (#1046300)
People didn't build IC fabs in their garages either. But we knew the ins and outs of the hardware. Some things are beyond human ability, but there seems to be much less interest in homebrewing our primary computing devices than I think that should account for.
Re:The Era of Black Boxes by pyre on Monday January 11, 2010 @10:36PM (#1046775)
I think it bears mentioning that at one point in time the hardware was the software for the most part. Now the hardware has grown powerful and general-purpose enough that it can largely be abstracted out of the picture for most applications (or at least abstracted to down to general high-level parts -- e.g. X Mb/Gb of RAM vs what type of controller chip is being used).

I think that most people that are interested in 'tinkering' with things are doing it in software instead of hardware.

Re:The Era of Black Boxes by jgrahamc on Monday January 11, 2010 @06:50AM (#1044896)
Agree. Reminded me of a post I made a while back about wanting to get back to simple system: http://www.jgc.org/blog/2009/08/just-give-me-simple-cpu-and-...

But there's a lot of fun to be had with Arduino. And non-digital electronics is still fun. Just go look at some of Forrest Mims' circuits in his original books. Lots of fun with a 555 timer.

Also, see the good Make: Electronics book from O'Reilly: http://www.makershed.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=9780...

Re:The Era of Black Boxes by imajes on Monday January 11, 2010 @07:14AM (#1044926)
@jgc: assuming you have this book, does it cover more than just the Make kit? I'm more interested in arduino than make stuff.

thanks!

Re:The Era of Black Boxes by evgen on Monday January 11, 2010 @06:20PM (#1046303)
The Make:Electronics book is probably not what you will want, it is more of an intro to electronics text. If your primary interest is the arduino and you are relatively comfortable with a soldering iron and circuit diagram then the book you are probably looking for is "Making Things Talk" (also from ORA.)
Re:The Era of Black Boxes by ericd on Monday January 11, 2010 @04:24PM (#1046051)
There are strong parallels in the programming world as well (with the exception that many of the big stacks are open source).

One of my favorite classes in school (CS major) was a microcontrollers lab class, wiring up simple processors and microcontrollers and then programming them in assembly. At that level, everything is transparent, there's no hazily-understood stack of abstracted layers written by others.

I think the reason I found it so refreshing was that transparency. The entire system could be viewed and understood at once.

On the other end of the spectrum you have something like Rails, where things happen seemingly by magic, and when they break, it's impossible to know why as a novice.