News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Sunday October 25, 2015 @04:18PM (#10448228)
Ask him for contemporary examples of philosophy's usefulness to science. While on the subject, you might want to argue that philosophy has become too self-referential to be relevant.

I don't think the Wikipedia phenomenon means a whole lot. Here's an alternative metaphor: philosophy is the pot we put all the loose ends in, until some advance in science allows us to work on them some more. That doesn't mean philosophy is making progress on them.

Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by shabda on Sunday October 25, 2015 @04:31PM (#10448277)
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Sunday October 25, 2015 @04:56PM (#10448388)
Philosophy is something of a grab-bag of disparate disciplines, and I agree that ethics can often (and should) inform public policy.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by foldr on Monday October 26, 2015 @05:56AM (#10450365)
> Philosophy is something of a grab bag of disparate disciplines

So is science.

Please don't tell me we're going to play that tedious game where we give you lots of examples of philosophy's relevance and your response is just "oh but I didn't mean that kind of philosophy".

Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:18AM (#10451167)
No, I am actually agreeing that this is a valid example, though it is not really a matter of science. As for all the other examples that you allude to, I will consider them case-by-case.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by littletimmy on Sunday October 25, 2015 @04:57PM (#10448396)
"Science" is not one enterprise. Read Thomas Kuhn in "The Structure of Scientific Revolutions." He divides science into two categories. The first is normal science, which is a period where the basic assumptions have been set, and scientists work within defined parameters to understand nature. In this period philosophy of not very relevant.

Kuhn says that this works well for a while, until there builds up a collection of anomalies that result in the second type of science: revolutionary science. For a short while, people start to question fundamental assumptions about their world and this results in a "paradigm shift". In this mode of science, philosophy has always been relevant. The philosopher Ernst Mach was relevant to Einstein, for example.

In our present age, we are at the stage of normal science started by Einstein and the quantum physicists. But anomalies have started building up. And when we enter into the new phase of revolutionary science, as happens every few hundred years, we'll see philosophy be relevant once more.

Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Sunday October 25, 2015 @05:13PM (#10448449)
Most of the time it is the scientists themselves who are questioning the current paradigms (Mach himself was a physicist). You might argue that they are working in philosopher-mode at that time, but they didn't usually get to be in a position to constructively question the paradigms through a study of academic philosophy.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by olavk on Sunday October 25, 2015 @04:43PM (#10448330)
How do you decide what is "science" in the first place? How do you distinguish science from pseudoscience or religion?
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Sunday October 25, 2015 @04:53PM (#10448381)
Science manages to figure that out without having to ask a philosopher.

The philosophy of science did not precede the development of science; in fact, it was the other way around.

Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mf_tomb on Sunday October 25, 2015 @05:33PM (#10448526)
There are still plenty of open questions. No one has just "figured out" confirmation and dealing with evidence. In fact, the way a lot science is done is incorrect and journals could learn a lot from Bayesian Epistemologists.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Sunday October 25, 2015 @06:10PM (#10448655)
These issues were raised from within the scientific community, which is well-equipped to deal with them.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by olavk on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:49PM (#10460615)
"without having to ask a philosopher"? What does that even mean? The distinction between scientist and philosophers is pretty recent. Clearly Aristotle was also a scientist even though we call him a philosopher, and clearly Bohr was also a philosopher even though we know him best as a scientist. Science and the philosophy of science have developed together, and often by the same people.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @08:34AM (#10464029)
>"without having to ask a philosopher"? What does that even mean?

I am at a loss as to how to be any clearer, but perhaps that's because I am looking at the whole sentence in the context of the thread. Could you be more specific about what problem you are having with it?

There was a time when people doing science were considered philosophers; at the same time, some of them were considered astrologers or alchemists - Newton was active in both of these fields, and that was not, as it seems to some people now, an aberration or contradiction. These philosophers / astrologers / alchemists synthesized the scientific method, but the modern philosophy of science is descriptive, not prescriptive: philosophers like Popper and Kuhn were describing the scientific method as it had already been developed by practicing scientists, without being led there by academic philosophy. The historical role of people, who now are or were then regarded as philosophers, in the early development of science does not imply that current science is behoven to current academic philosophy.

Your attempt to conflate philosophy and science raises the question of why a university would need an independent philosophy department, and I think you would find its members to be the ones most strongly defending its existence. If you were to go to the top of this thread, you would find that the distinction between science and philosophy is being made by pierrec’s philosopher-student friend. If you want to argue that there is no meaningful difference, perhaps you should first persuade the people who identify themselves as philosophers.

Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by olavk on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @05:08PM (#10467432)
My point is that figuring out what constitutes science is philosophy, regardless of who does the figuring out. It's not like it is science if a scientist does the thinking but philosophy if someone from the philosophy department does the same.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @07:22PM (#10468122)
The problem with this line of argument is that one could just as well say that logic is philosophy, so anyone who reasons about anything is a philosopher... it is not so much a wrong argument as it is a pointless one, leading to a trite and unhelpful conclusion that strips the word 'philosopher' of any useful meaning. In the context established by pierrec's original post, a more meaningful question is 'what contributions are academic philosophers currently making to the sciences?'

Then there's the fact that you have ended up agreeing with me that scientists can do it themselves.

Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by olavk on Thursday October 29, 2015 @04:12AM (#10469761)
Of course scientists can do philosophy, that was my point in mentioning Bohr as an example. And before modern specialization there was no clear distinction between philosophy and science, and for example Kant also did natural science even though he is most well known as a philosopher

Logic has traditionally (at least since Aristotle) been considered a critical branch of philosophy.

Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Thursday October 29, 2015 @07:21AM (#10470229)
Neither of these facts refute any of the points I have made in this thread. Perhaps it would help if you were to state clearly what point you think you are making here, and why that point belongs in this thread.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by olavk on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:05PM (#10472542)
That science needs philosophy like a hand needs a thumb.
Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:53PM (#10475710)
Here I get to say, with reason in this case, what does that even mean?

You apparently practice the passive-aggressive school of philosophy - the one where you write as if you are disagreeing with someone, but you neither offer any specific rebuttals of the other's arguments, nor do you make any specific, refutable statements about your own position.

But none of this matters anyway. If you want to argue that science needs philosophy, and regardless of what metaphor you are trying to pass off as an actual argument, the one thing you have to do is to show one or more significant examples where contemporary science has depended on contemporary philosophy. Without that, anything else is just talking around the issue. Of all the people who have replied to this thread, only shabda seems to understand this.

Re:Getting to “Philosophy” by mannykannot on Friday October 30, 2015 @09:09PM (#10481423)
I came back to edit this (but I am too late) because I think I am being unnecessarily confrontational. Here is how I would reply today:

I get your point that scientists sometimes do things that can be described as philosophy in the broad sense, but generally, I do not think they would be able to do that if they had been educated in academic philosophy. I believe Bohr himself falls into this category. It would be more accurate to say that philosophy is dependent on science in these matters.

I also get the point that scientists use the scientific method that was developed by people who can be called philosophers, but they developed science through doing it, and that is not a dependent relationship even if you call what they did philosophy.

With regard to examples, I am sticking with my position that they are the only argument that really counts (which is why I suggested it to pierrec), but I don’t think there are none: for example, I think Daniel Dennett has made many valuable contributions to cognitive science, and made a number of trenchant observations with regard to the expectations of computational neurologists.