Re:There are no rules in math
by jschwartzi on Sunday October 25, 2015 @03:47PM
(#10448095)
I had a college geometry professor who taught all of his classes this way. He taught me things about math, structure, elegance, and beauty that unfolded into a much better understanding of why math is so powerful in science. Studying history of math and Euclid did more to enhance my understanding of Physics and Math than any of the actual required courses, because they taught me the context in which the thinking is grown, which is far more powerful than the thinking itself.
I found it to be the most important glue in my math education. In fact, all the natural science ought to be taught in this way. Kinda like Bill Bryson's Brief History of Everything, plus actual calculations.
We won a math contest in my last year. I was expecting it to stay interesting.
Unfortunately when I got to university math (and the rest of engineering) was taught in a very utilitarian way. There was very little context, just a lot of similar looking derivations.
I blame the exam culture. In a way it's good because it motivates you to learn something, but it's bad because you end up learning it in a way that isn't useful. At the end of your college days, you are unlikely to remember just how Stoke's theorem works or the coefficients in Runge-Kutta. That's just because the size of the curriculum is huge. But if you had a context, a set of stories about when and why something was studied, you'd have a much better chance of being able to recall that it even exists.