Re:Study says standardized testing is overwhelming nation’s ...
by tboyd47 on Sunday October 25, 2015 @01:34PM
(#10447567)
I'm not saying there aren't any valid reasons for doing it. I'm just saying the there's a "meta-lesson" there that has to be corrected. I want all my kids to grow up knowing that there's no shame in saying "I don't know," if you honestly don't know. Life is not a sounding smart contest.
Re:Study says standardized testing is overwhelming nation’s ...
by 336f5 on Sunday October 25, 2015 @07:22PM
(#10448871)
>> Why they do this, I have no idea.
> I'm not saying there aren't any valid reasons for doing it.
> I'm just saying the there's a "meta-lesson" there that has to be corrected.
And I'm saying that your meta-lesson is not a good idea as it will tend to teach underconfidence. The real world does not always let you off with a "I don't know"; you may not know to some high degree of certainty whether a cancer treatment is a good idea, but nevertheless you must decide whether or not to do it.
(Imagine a test of 10 questions, each substantially harder; one student manages to answer correctly up to question 5 before starting to feel uncertain and refusing to answer any more, and a second gets up to question 6. How sure are you that #1 knows less than #2? Now imagine that they instead 'guessed' on the remaining 5 questions, and #1 got 3/5 right and #2 got 1/4. Now how sure are you? Haven't you learned something from this apparently 'useless' guessing?)
> But in the real world, there is no 25% credit for guessing.
You can no more refuse to guess in the real world than you can refuse to make choices, take actions, or let time pass.