Edit: I should say though, right on for pointing out the material issue. You got the meat of it right in that it's overall spending that matters, not just income tax. You "showed your work" correctly, you just plugged in the wrong numbers. That means you get an 8/10 from me.
Edit2: I read the parent's post too quickly in my haste to make a point. However, neither of us considered the contribution of local taxes, as discussed below. I believe that that definitively answers the question of which state spends more per capita.
Additionally, timr was correct to restrict his numbers to state tax revenue, which is the total under discussion.
If you do the math, it comes out to $6,500 per person in Teaxs, and $5,600 per person in California. So even considering the other sources of revenue (though it makes no sense to do so in this context), timr's point is still correct.
and here (Texas State Per Capita Revenue numbers) 2010E - State: $2980; State+Local: $7041 http://www.usgovernmentrevenue.com/TX_per_capita_revenue.htm...
These tie better back to the US Census numbers (which are only as at 2004 but are on an apples-apples basis): http://www.census.gov/govs/state/04rank.html
The problem is that states do not report revenues in the same ways and some are clearly more creative than others.
From the same Texas source, table A-12, the estimated total state revenue is $39.3 Bn for fiscal 2009. Thus, the per-capita revenue numbers for fiscal 2009 would be $1,617.30, versus $2,391 for California. So, I'm wrong. Texas takes in about 32% less per capita than California.
Given the eternal train-wreck that is California budgeting -- even in good years, they just give away the store in future obligations (like public pensions) that make the bad years twice as bad -- fewer, longer budgets might be a good idea here as well.
That's slightly higher than the per-year figure in the original comment:
I don't think he's correct.
Shows California State's per capita consumption/expense at $6,397.23 / $5,686.48
For Texas State it's $4,030.37 / $3,441.53
Granted, it's 2004 numbers but at least it's more certain the numbers are being compared on the same basis.
As a human being I'm responsible for managing my own budget: if I spend more than I earn, I suffer the consequences. Government, including California's, doesn't seem to view reducing outgoings as a possibility, and thus is obsessed with increasing incomings. One of its approaches to doing so has been to maintain a high tax rate.
You have to weigh reduced spending with the consequences of that, and sometimes maybe running a deficit is better.
That's not to paint too rosy a picture- California is doing plenty of absurd things with its money, but much of that is mandated by the propositions, not a choice by the legislature (Three strikes means more, unavoidable, prison expenses, the high speed rail bond fiasco, the extravagant research bonds that inevitably get approved and squandered).
Despite the fact that all of my interlocutors had university educations, sometimes including PhDs, all were so deeply invested in the idea that their insolvent state government is starved for revenue that they were unable to parse the information."
Perhaps they were just stunned that someone with a PhD doesn't know that income tax isn't the whole story?
California state revenue, 2009: $88 Billion (source: http://www.ebudget.ca.gov/pdf/BudgetSummary/SummaryCharts.pd..., chart SUM-01)
California population: 36.8 million (July, 2008; source: US Census)
CA Revenue per capita: $2391.30
Texas state revenue, 2009: $78 Billion (source: http://www.cpa.state.tx.us/taxbud/bre2008/BRE_2008-09.pdf, page 3)
Texas population: 24.3 million (July, 2008; source: US Census)
TX Revenue per capita: $3209.88
"Conservative" Texas takes in almost a thousand bucks more per person in taxes and fees than does "liberal" California.
UPDATE: I made a mistake. The numbers for Texas are reported on a biennial basis, whereas for California, they're reported on an annual basis. See my reply to cwan below for details. When you get the annual numbers from the Texas budget summary, they appear to take in about 32% less per capita than California.