News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by andrewvc on Sunday January 10, 2010 @07:44PM (#1044010)
This looks like nothing but BS to me, there's a reason this is in the NYT's Style section.

The most telling quote from the article is “I didn’t want to do some faddish diet that my sister would do,” Mr. Durant said. This just reeks of pathetic insecurity, I'm not surprised the conclusions he came to were ridiculous.

Apparently, there's not even much of a consensus about what people used to eat back then. According to Wikipedia: However, there is little direct evidence of the relative proportions of plant and animal foods.[94] According to some anthropologists and advocates of the modern Paleolithic diet, Paleolithic hunter-gatherers consumed a significant amount of meat and possibly obtained most of their food from hunting.[95] Competing hypotheses suggest that Paleolithic humans may have consumed a plant-based diet in general,[58] or that hunting and gathering possibly contributed equally to their diet.[96] One hypothesis is that carbohydrate tubers (plant underground storage organs) may have been eaten in high amounts by our pre-agricultural humans.[97][98][99][100] However, the relative proportions of plant and animal foods in the diets of Paleolithic peoples probably varied between regions. For instance, hunter gatherers in tropical regions such as Africa probably consumed a plant-based diet, while populations in colder regions such as Northern Europe most likely obtained most of their food from meat.[101] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleolithic#Diet_and_nutrition

This whole thing smacks of a silly trend among a small group of NY hipsters to sound cool and eat a shit load of meat.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by n8agrin on Sunday January 10, 2010 @09:01PM (#1044114)
I think the "paleos", as it were, are quite serious and don't think of this as just a "silly trend".

That said, whether or not there truly is any nutritional benefit over eating, say 80% vegetables, and going to the gym is probably hard to prove. I'm willing to bet that most of the benefit these people see is from the commitment to a regimented diet and exercise program, and not the specific diet they are eating. But that's just my uninformed, naive guess.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by andrewvc on Sunday January 10, 2010 @09:38PM (#1044172)
Well, there are two issues in my post. 1.) Is the Paleo diet legitimate, and 2.) Is it attracting some douche bag followers.

The answer to the question of whether the movement is attracting idiots is, as evidenced by this article, a clear yes. This is shown in silly comments like: “Another caveman trick involves donating blood frequently. The idea is that various hardships might have occasionally left ancient humans a pint short.”.

The answer to whether the diet is legitimate is I don't quite know. My suspicion is there are things to learn from it, but let's not forget, we aren't cavemen anymore.

The big question for me is does the caveman diet (and there are more than one at this point) work without the caveman lifestyle, and that really would require long term studies, not anecdotes, which is all we see so far.

That being said, it's almost certainly better than the highly processed food most Americans eat right now, but that hardly makes it a first choice for a diet.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by nunb on Monday January 11, 2010 @12:21AM (#1044414)
As for #2, imho, the article is deliberately written to caricaturize, which may well be appropriate for a mainstream lifestyle section of a newspaper. IIRC, an earlier article in the same paper on the crossfit exercise plan was quite alarmist (implied neophytes would by dying like flies) and dismissive. Vegan and yoga are the accepted modes of the NYC healthy lifestyle :-)

> we aren't cavemen anymore

In behavior and lifestyle, no. But in terms of the evolutionary stage of our digestive systems? Lactose tolerance [Lactose], for example is quite new (and beneficial enough that it spread rapidly).

The mechanisms described in the "Expensive tissue hypothesis" still apply. [Eades] has a nice description.

[Eades] http://www.proteinpower.com/drmike/low-carb-library/are-we-m...

[Lactose] http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/08/090827202513.ht...

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by wisty on Sunday January 10, 2010 @10:43PM (#1044266)
Regular blood donations? Yep, that's crazy. People who lost a lot of blood tended to get infections, then die. Which is why the average life expectancy was about 30.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by nradov on Monday January 11, 2010 @02:47AM (#1044625)
There is some evidence that high blood iron levels increases the risk of heart attack and stroke. So donating blood regularly may actually be good for you.

http://www.webmd.com/news/20001025/too-much-iron-may-lead-to...

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by jenningsjason on Monday January 11, 2010 @11:06PM (#1046825)
"Average" life expectancy is deceiving. Much of the gains in human life expectancy have come from reductions in infant and childhood mortality, which alters the average substantially.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by tokenadult on Monday January 11, 2010 @12:16AM (#1044402)
Regular blood donations? Yep, that's crazy.

I'm up above nine gallons donated, lifetime, and I'm ready to give more as the occasion allows. I'm much above the age of thirty, considerably above the model age of most readers of HN.

https://www.givelife.org/

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by wisty on Sunday January 10, 2010 @10:39PM (#1044254)
Jared Diamond drew an analogy between New Guinea tribes and paleo diets. If modern hunter-gatherers are similar to paleo hunter-gatherers, the women gather most of the calories (tubers, some fruits, grain) and the men hunt a little meat if they are lucky.

Colder regions might have had more meat consumption (look at modern Inuit), but those were the last holdouts of the Neanderthals (by some accounts). Humans won the cold regions by becoming smart technical hunters, not Spaaaartans.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by kingkongreveng_ on Sunday January 10, 2010 @11:08PM (#1044299)
New Guniea tribes are post agricultural. They indicate nothing about "paleo" tendencies.

There are no living or even especially recent hunter gatherer models to look at. People sometimes point to african bushmen, but they're stunted refugees scraping by on marginal wasteland. They don't match up with the consistently strong and healthy native american hunter gatherer skeletons.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by mtts on Monday January 11, 2010 @08:50AM (#1045062)
Presumably Jared Diamond was talking about the New Guinea tribes in the lowlands that are in fact rather "paleo" and not about the inhabitants of the mountain ranges of the interior who practice agriculture and where the men don't, in fact, hunt very much.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by TheSOB88 on Monday January 11, 2010 @12:10AM (#1044390)
What about the Amazon? They've remained untouched for a while.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by tlack on Sunday January 10, 2010 @09:19PM (#1044136)
So you're saying human evolution (what our bodies have evolved to digest and process over the past half million years) should have no bearing on what we eat today? I think that's the silly part.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by Retric on Sunday January 10, 2010 @09:28PM (#1044153)
We are omnivores like raccoons, we can and did eat just about anything from plants and fresh kills to rotting meat and insects. We gorged on fruit when in season and starved when we could not find anything. We even eat each other and feces like dogs from time to time. Which is why we can still eat just about anything for long periods of time and survive.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by nunb on Monday January 11, 2010 @12:24AM (#1044419)
I like to say that the fact that humans are omnivores is descriptive, not prescriptive.

That we can use alternate food sources in times of hardship is a survival mechanism. IOW, omnivory is not a preferred mode of eating (genetically/evolutionarily speaking).

Individually of course, we may prefer omnivory, frugivory, x-vory.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by kingkongreveng_ on Sunday January 10, 2010 @10:39PM (#1044256)
Yes we can digest fructose. And when people found honey (basically pure fructose) I'm sure they gorged on it. But as a few links on the front page of this site have explained in recent days, fructose is borderline toxic.

Anthropological research in conjunction with modern medical research convincingly indicate several foods cause disease. The fact that we can digest all kinds of things is irrelevant.

It pretty much all boils down to avoiding sugars, grain products, and certain oils. It's a very easy case to buy if you read into it.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by Retric on Sunday January 10, 2010 @11:11PM (#1044302)
Whole grain bread is the foundation of western civilization for a reason. It contains a huge assortment of what the human body needs as a single food source. Combined with a little meat and a little fruit and a human go go from a child to live a long and healthy life eating nothing else. However, you can also make a healthy diet by completely avoiding it. A large part of a healthy diet is variety and while that can be a pain in our modern society blaming any single highly refined food as horrible while ignoring the other components of your diet is missing a large part of the story.

The less verity in a persons diet the closer to perfection what they do eat needs to be. When you consider the quantity of fructose in the average American diet of course there is a problem, but mainly because of what it replaces and not what it is. If you burned 4k calories a day and drink 1k worth of sucrose water you can still have a healthy if unusual diet. However, when you are only consuming 2k worth of calories a day 50% of which provides zero nutrition your body is probably missing out on important things.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by kingkongreveng_ on Sunday January 10, 2010 @11:17PM (#1044314)
> bread is the foundation of western civilization

Yes, and there is a panoply of diseases only people eating grain get. They're referred to as the "diseases of civilization."

Do your own reading. I did mine and concluded bread intake should be minimized, whole grain or not.

Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by vorador on Monday January 11, 2010 @06:49AM (#1044893)
I don't think that this appellation is correct ; iirc, at a time, homosexuality too was considered a disease of civilisation.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by andrewvc on Sunday January 10, 2010 @09:24PM (#1044145)
Wow, you completely misread what I wrote. I wrote that these particular people are eating what they believe is a caveman diet, though in fact it is no more than their own wishful food fantasy, with almost no grounding in history or science.
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by baddox on Sunday January 10, 2010 @09:24PM (#1044144)
Do you think paleolithic man researched their own distant ancestors to figure out what to eat? I personally doubt it. Why should we?
Re:The New Cavemen Lifestyle by nunb on Monday January 11, 2010 @12:35AM (#1044435)
Precisely because paleo man was more animal-like. Less cerebration was involved in deciding what to eat. Animals don't synthesize textured protein from soybean, they eat what is natural (instinctive) for them to eat, to the extent that Amazonian parakeets (and many other species) eat a particular kind of clay to neutralize the toxins they ingest in their fruit-based diet.

If we do synthesize our food, and process it more than any other animal, we should consider whether what we're doing is good for us.