News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by crdoconnor on Friday October 23, 2015 @08:12AM (#10438070)
>Nobody has ever explained to me, in a satisfying way, what's wrong with a helicopter drop.

The main effect would be a a transfer of wealth from debtors to the indebted, a hit of inflation and an economic stimulus effect.

The economic multiplier would not be as high as something like SNAP (which is about 2.5-3.5x I think), since the middle classes and rich recipients would just squirrel away what they got. Or use it to pay down debts. It would have a higher economic multiplier than pretty much any money that's been funneled into bailouts though.

Whether all this is "good" depends on your perspective.

Practically speaking, though, any potential helicopter drop is going to be so small it will have virtually no effect. At the same time, it'll be demonized every step of the way by the people who would hate the precedent it would set (i.e. anybody who is owed money).

I think whatever your desired effect is there's probably a better tool to achieve it than a helicopter drop. It's a fairly blunt tool.

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by aljones on Friday October 23, 2015 @08:26AM (#10438134)
Why is a helicopter drop more prone to inflation than QE? Presume we're in a liquidity trap as the proponents of helicopter drops and QE do.

Edit: I have misinterpreted what you said. I read your first sentence as explaining what was wrong with a helicopter drop of money, because that is what was asked. However you probably didn't mean that to be a list of bad effects, just effects, to set the stage for your real answer which is the multiplier. Which is indeed the most important thing to consider.

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by yummyfajitas on Friday October 23, 2015 @09:02AM (#10438274)
A helicopter drop will put money into the hands of poor people, causing them to consume. Concretely, a poor person might eat more. This makes food prices (included in CPI) go up, hence inflation.

In contrast, QE might also stimulate investment. Concretely, we might build a factory or a road. This makes industrial machinery prices (not included in CPI) go up, hence no inflation.

Since the goal of stimulus is to reduce real wages and induce workers to stop turning down productive labor, the former is more useful than the latter. Of course, there are countervailing effects - giving workers money directly can substitute for them getting a job. (See my other post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10438248 )

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by asgard1024 on Friday October 23, 2015 @05:24PM (#10441384)
What you're saying doesn't make sense. Why would anyone invest without expecting more consumption?

The economy cycle doesn't start with investing, it starts at consumers having money and giving them to someone in exchange for a service or product. How could you know what to invest in before there is even demand?

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by yummyfajitas on Friday October 23, 2015 @05:37PM (#10441431)
There is clearly demand present, given that we have not (as an economy) reverted to 100% subsistence farming. In any case, you don't need to expect an increase in consumption to invest - one can simply expect to steal customers from the other guy. Uber's investors didn't expect Uber to create new rides, merely to steal riders from the cartels.

Of course, if you are correct that no one will invest, then all the money from QE will be funneled into consumption. This will have the same effect as the helicopter drop, modulo distribution.

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by asgard1024 on Friday October 23, 2015 @06:15PM (#10441544)
What I mean is that there can't be more investment without more demand. In the Uber example, there won't be more investment either - if you expect Uber to grow on behalf of other companies, these will be divested. In fact, you could expect decrease of investment with Uber, like with any other new technology (disputable in Uber's case, but for the sake of argument), because the whole point of moving to new technology is to decrease investment needed to maintain the same level of consumption (that is, increase productivity).

> all the money from QE will be funneled into consumption

They are, after sitting there idly for a while. The bank CEOs have to pay their mistresses and so on.

And distribution is important too. The whole problem of debt deflation is that you have money sitting idly (or better say idly circulating in an endless vortex of financial machinations), not being spent on goods and services.

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by yummyfajitas on Friday October 23, 2015 @06:49PM (#10441643)
I think you are confusing investment and cost of operation. Investment is building the new technology, cost of operation is the cost of providing consumption. Increasing investment today will indeed increase production in the future - that's the whole point.

*They are, after sitting there idly for a while. The bank CEOs have to pay their mistresses and so on...money sitting idly..."

The production is either consumed, invested, spent on government or exported. P=C+I+G+NX. You seem to believe it can be neither C nor I (well sometimes), so are the wealthy spending all their unconsumed income on government or exports?

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by asgard1024 on Friday October 23, 2015 @07:12PM (#10441730)
> Increasing investment today will indeed increase production in the future - that's the whole point.

So you agree that for the investment to be worth it (and thus made), consumption in the future must increase (or at least appear that it will increase to the investor)? That was my point.

> The production is either consumed, invested, spent on government or exported.

I talked about money, not production. Money can be saved, or in today's world more likely, ran around in circles through the financial system, without ever causing more consumption to happen.

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 24, 2015 @07:46AM (#10443299)
No, for the investment to be worth it the return needs to exceed the risk free rate.

If your sole claim about money is that there needs to be a functioning monetary system so that the consumer can easily transfer value to the producer, I agree.

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by crdoconnor on Saturday October 24, 2015 @04:27AM (#10442896)
>What you're saying doesn't make sense. Why would anyone invest without expecting more consumption?

Exactly. That bit was dumb. Hence why industrial machinery didn't shoot up in price like the cost of a 2 bedroom semi in San Fran did.

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 24, 2015 @08:59AM (#10443458)
Industrial machinery didn't crazily shoot up in price because NIMBYs haven't made it illegal to produce more.

Housing prices in SF are entirely a self-inflicted ill - NIMBYs causing scarcity. Houston does it right: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/03/hou...

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by collyw on Monday October 26, 2015 @12:27PM (#10452425)
QE seems to have had the effect of keeping asset prices high and not much more.
Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by dragonwriter on Friday October 23, 2015 @01:21PM (#10439958)
> The main effect would be a transfer of wealth from debtors to the indebted

"debtors" and "the indebted" are different names for the same group. I think you mean "debtors to creditors".

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by tormeh on Friday October 23, 2015 @10:01AM (#10438562)
>Or use it to pay down debts.

Paying down debt is stabilizing, though, so it's not wasted.

Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by vlehto on Friday October 23, 2015 @10:14AM (#10438645)
What is SNAP?
Re:Decline in the labor share of income in the U.S. by Spellman on Friday October 23, 2015 @01:15PM (#10439926)