Re:Wendelstein 7-X – a fusion reactor with a twist
by onion2k on Friday October 23, 2015 @03:33AM
(#10437314)
I'm always amazed and impressed by the people who work on these giant projects. To do all that engineering without really knowing if it'll even work in the end must require a huge amount of confidence in both yourself and the rest of the team.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X – a fusion reactor with a twist
by Faint on Friday October 23, 2015 @08:46AM
(#10438217)
Confidence, or conscious willingness to take steps to unknown (will to explore)?
Re:Wendelstein 7-X – a fusion reactor with a twist
by dest on Friday October 23, 2015 @04:11AM
(#10437406)
Furthermore, if the technology works eventually, you may already be retired (if not passed away!)
In my opinion, the motivation rather comes from the fascinating scientific questions behind those projects. Whether it works as an industry may be "just a plus".
Disclaimer: did a phd in tokamaks / experimental data crunching
Re:Wendelstein 7-X – a fusion reactor with a twist
by adrianN on Friday October 23, 2015 @04:32AM
(#10437468)
Well, even if it ends up not working, you learned a lot along the way. Ambitious engineering efforts are never completely wasted.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X – a fusion reactor with a twist
by theoh on Friday October 23, 2015 @12:32PM
(#10439652)
Maybe this is pedantic but it does look like it has fivefold rotational symmetry, which makes it a lot more regular than a typical car body, for example. Still, complex geometry.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X – a fusion reactor with a twist
by skimpycompiler on Friday October 23, 2015 @03:18PM
(#10440723)
Yeah, it was probably something symmetrical in the laws that allowed them to simulate only single part of the coil - saving the computing time and lowering the search space, stacking up resulted in full coil.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X – a fusion reactor with a twist
by theoh on Friday October 23, 2015 @05:48PM
(#10441458)
I'm not sure about the laws you refer to. It seems to me that the constraint is that for a twisting ribbon-like plasma they had to have an integral number of twists or half twists in a complete circuit, not twisting too sharply, not too gradually.
It so interesting to look at the shape of the coil, nothing regular. Shapes optimized by a super computer, who knows what algorithms they've used there, what kind of search was it, how many parameters, how long did the simulation last.