So, when you say it's part of an effort to standardize behavior, I think you're right. But is this the right way to go? I mean, was the old behavior that bad? Why not just flag it as a warning and mark it as deprecated functionality? Then wait until version 6 to actually force the change.
I don't have a horse in this race, since I stopped using PHP when 5 was just coming out. One of those reasons was to avoid stuff like this...
Further I agree with what Rasmus states as one of his last remarks in that bug thread: "Wow, a classic case of how not to treat unpaid volunteers who provide critical pieces of your money-making infrastructure."
In other words, go make yourself a programming language if you have a big mouth towards volunteers when you scheme of making money with their system fails you, the bloody arrogance.
Go PHP!