News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by TimMeade on Thursday October 22, 2015 @03:54PM (#10434610)
Not to be the naysayer on this but it is a very serious incursion on states rights. The legal consensus i'm hearing is that it will be overturned by the judicial system.

Does the FCC have the right to tell a state or town what to do with local calls? That is the root of this. It's a given that they can regulate interstate, but historically intrastate has been the rights of the states.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 22, 2015 @03:55PM (#10434619)
In the event this is overturned judicially, I intend to incorporate a 501c3 non-profit (or B Corp, depending on the legalities) to provide these services at-cost to deep six Securus Technologies' profiting off of this.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by vonmoltke on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:12PM (#10434737)
Why do you think that will work? If it was that easy, Securus would already have competitors.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:14PM (#10434751)
I intend to use lobbying efforts in concert with a technical solution, even if I have to go state by state. Everyone here hustles for something different; I hustle for a better (imho) world. I cannot sit back and watch shitty people be shitty.

Each personal project I work on is technical primarily, but each requires me to involve myself more in the political process by design. Technology alone will not change things, so I must get better at the people part of the process to enact the change I wish to see.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by smt88 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:34PM (#10434858)
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by nickalewis on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:20PM (#10435166)
We should talk; My goals with Penmate[1] are somewhat similar. Technology can and _will_ disrupt this

[1] http://penmateapp.com

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by smt88 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:37PM (#10434884)
It's probably time to give up on the ridiculous sanctity of states' rights.

It made sense in a time when people lived in same state their whole lives, rarely traveled outside the state, and rarely communicated outside the state. Their whole lives unfolded within a few hundred square miles.

That's not the case anymore. You can't subdivide the interests of American citizens by state anymore. What does it mean to be from Ohio vs. Indiana? Almost nothing.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by ctdonath on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:16PM (#10435142)
Still means a lot. Cherry-picking a pair that differs little ignores the vast differences between other pairs. I moved from NY to GA; there's a deep cultural difference, and much that's desirable norm in one is nigh unto intolerable in the other (both ways). Wyoming is a very different lifestyle from California from Florida from Virginia from Maine etc. Drives many of us crazy that concentrated urbanites in one region want to boss around country folk living very different lifestyles/values/history, and do so due to sheer concentrated numbers.

Whatever happened to "celebrate [and protect] diversity"?

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by ak4g on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:25PM (#10435864)
I disagree. Grew up in NC, spent a year and change in NYC, in SF for the last two years.

The biggest difference was the cost of a pack of cigarettes, when I still smoked. Now the biggest difference is the weather, which I gather varies quite a lot just within CA.

My coworkers are variously local and transplants like myself, and I wouldn't be able to tell except for being told.

One of the effects of the last half-century of mass media is the wholesale homogenization of American culture. I'm fine with this, and I wish our political structures would adapt accordingly; I happen to think American norms of 2015 are considerably better than North Carolina's norms circa 1965.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by martinpw on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:24PM (#10436472)
> Drives many of us crazy that concentrated urbanites in one region want to boss around country folk living very different lifestyles/values/history, and do so due to sheer concentrated numbers

Strange that you pick that example since that happens within a single state too. In fact it seems like there is a much larger difference between urban and rural regions within any given state then there is between urban regions (or rural regions) across different states.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by SilasX on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:51PM (#10435684)
What about when your particular state wants to deviate from the national norm on, say, drug policy or gay marriage (in favor)?
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by smt88 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:07PM (#10435772)
Several states already do that with legalized marijuana. The federal government has chosen not to get involved, so it's become a de facto state's right.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by SilasX on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:42PM (#10435932)
So, you're against states' rights, except when you agree with the particular policy the state is following in defiance of the federal government.

That's not a criticism of states' rights; that's a criticism of not agreeing with you. Join the club :-p

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by smt88 on Friday October 23, 2015 @03:19AM (#10437275)
I was stating a fact. I didn't express my opinion of it one way or the other.

My point was that we already have examples where there are exceptions to federal law on a state-by-state basis. What I've been saying all along is that we should codify that system.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by SilasX on Friday October 23, 2015 @12:30PM (#10439641)
So "giving up on states rights" = codifying the system, and this:

>It's probably time to give up on the ridiculous sanctity of states' rights.

isn't an opinion? I'm lost.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by thaumasiotes on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:06PM (#10435073)
What does it mean to be from Seattle vs. Vancouver?
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by michael_fine on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:28PM (#10435219)
You're right, in an ideal world it would mean nothing, as country distinctions are mostly arbitrary. However, there doesn't exist, and most likely won't exist in the near future, a world government that can realitistically replace all of the country governments, which is why it's not worth calling for the imminent removal of 'country rights'.

However, in the case of states, there is a organizing body that can, and is increasingly governing in their stead -- the federal government. And as many people believe the federal government has on average done a better job, that is why there are calls for the retirement of the 'states rights' concept.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by thaumasiotes on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:33PM (#10435590)
The cultural (and physical!) distance between Seattle and Vancouver is minimal. Seattle is closer in basically every sense to Vancouver than it is to Salt Lake City. It can't make any sense to call for a unified Seattle-Salt Lake City government before a unified Seattle-Vancouver government. Applying the same policies to Seattle and to Salt Lake City is going to make one of those groups very unhappy.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by plonh on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:14PM (#10435122)
"States rights" only gets brought up when the Repulicans don't like a Federal decision. If they'd quit the special pleading, people might believe them.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by harryh on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:41PM (#10434903)
What does it mean to be from Hawaii vs. Mississippi? Kind of a lot?
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by smt88 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:45PM (#10434922)
I'm not saying states shouldn't be able to determine certain things. But the federal government should be able to overrule asinine state policies after public debate (still subject to testing in court).

When that testing happens, as it does now, the determining factor shouldn't be "states vs federal rights". It should be, "Does this state have a good reason to differ from the rest of the country?"

In this case, where inmates' families are being harmed, there is no reason for Hawaii to differ from Mississippi.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by harryh on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:53PM (#10434981)
Maybe in a poorer state like Mississippi the revenue state raised by more expensive phone calls is needed to properly pay for the prisons in question?

I'm not saying I believe that argument, but I don't live in Mississippi, I don't pay taxes in Mississippi, and I'm extremely unlikely to ever end up in a Mississippi prison. Maybe it should be the job of Mississippians to weigh the pros and cons of these things?

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by smt88 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:00PM (#10435028)
I understand that you're proposing something hypothetical. So let's assume that it's true: Mississippi needs the revenue to run the prisons.

The federal government should be able to say, "No, sorry Mississippi, you aren't going to run your prisons on the backs of the families of inmates."

Why should someone have to pay extortionist prices to speak to a loved one? They likely had nothing to do with the crime (or the criminality of the inmate), and it's not fair to punish them just for being unlucky enough to love someone who becomes a convict.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by harryh on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:05PM (#10435071)
I'm pretty sure that the loved ones of prisoners are being punished (by, you know, being physically separated from the prisoners) regardless of the cost of phone calls. Again, I'm not saying you're wrong. Were I a Mississippian, I'd prolly be in favor of cheaper phone calls for prisoners. But aren't we drawing a line in kind of a weird place?

  - OK to lock someone up in a cage.
  - OK to charge them $0.11/minute to talk to someone outside of that cage.
  - NOT OK to charge $1/minute to talk to someone outside of that cage.
And given how weird that line is, should it really be drawn by outsiders who feel no effects of where the line is drawn?
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:35PM (#10435597)
> And given how weird that line is, should it really be drawn by outsiders who feel no effects of where the line is drawn?

Yes. That how treating humans humanely works.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by harryh on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:11PM (#10435792)
Why are outsiders better equipped to decide what is and is not humane than members of the actual community in question?
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:13PM (#10435806)
Because human rights are, as they say, "inalienable"; the local community doesn't get to vote on them.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by harryh on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:19PM (#10435839)
Inexpensive phone calls are a human right?

Keep in mind this wasn't a ruling by SCOTUS citing the constitution. It was a ruling by the FCC meaning that ultimately it WAS a community voting on them. The only debate here is the size of the community that should get a vote.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:23PM (#10435861)
You are free to your opinion. Preventing someone from keeping in touch with their family while they're in prison through extortion-level pricing of communications services is violating their rights, and the FCC appears to agree. If it has to go to SCOTUS, so be it.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:57PM (#10435010)
If you can't pay for your prisons without extorting the families of convicts, stop locking people up.
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by ams6110 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:12PM (#10436595)
You seem to misunderstand the entire notion of limited federal government as defined in the constitution.

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by arcticbull on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:44PM (#10436676)
Don't you think that ship has sailed? That's simply not true anymore, and it might be time to recognize that. Just look at the way federal funds set speed limits nationwide. Turns out if you set the right incentive structure, it just doesn't matter as rights are set aside in exchange for compensation.

I think ultimately the federal government gets what it wants because it holds the biggest purse-strings and that's all that matters at the end of the day.

Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by liveoneggs on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:00PM (#10435036)
other than racial demographics, what does it mean?
Re:The FCC has voted to end exorbitant phone fees for prison... by s73v3r on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:27PM (#10435565)
States rights once again got it wrong. I am not upset at all that the federal government stepped in and fixed it. I am upset that the states themselves allowed this to happen.