News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Of kimono and cultural appropriation by exogen on Thursday October 22, 2015 @02:48AM (#10430760)
It's very tempting to say that, but that's a bit of a privileged stance. ("I wouldn't mind, so nobody else should mind either!")

Analogy: Let's say you take a free intro taekwondo class. They outfit you with a white belt, obviously. But you think the red/black belt looks cool, so you start wearing that instead - maybe not in the dojang even, but just around town. You don't think martial artists should have a problem with that, maybe even challenge you to a fight? And even non-martial-artists shouldn't think you're kind of a poser?

Re:Of kimono and cultural appropriation by ohsnap on Thursday October 22, 2015 @03:06AM (#10430801)
Or say a foreigner is introduced to Jiu Jitsu. Then that said foreigner appropriates it and develops a new system called Brazilian Jiu Jitsu. They then issue belts based on their new interpretation of skill level. Perhaps a few Japanese might have a problem with that and think your a 'poser' - but you would probably ignore them and just consider them a bigot.
Re:Of kimono and cultural appropriation by iSnow on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:19AM (#10431223)
I don't really understand where the foreign culture is needed.

If you walk around in army uniform and have never been in the army, you will invite criticism or even a kick in the butt. If you dress up as a nun or as a priest you are an impostor. If you decide it's cool to wear the "Ring of O" on your right hand, you'll invite some inconvenient misunderstandings - especially as a woman.

Everyone should be aware of societal codes and either obey them or live with the resulting misunderstandings. Shrugging your shoulders and violating those codes makes you a not nice person at worst, but casting this in "oppressive west vs. the rest" terms just muddies the water.

Re:Of kimono and cultural appropriation by lucozade on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:00AM (#10431357)
> You don't think martial artists should have a problem with that

No they shouldn't. It in no ways diminishes the value or meaning of a red/black belt in taekwondo.

However, if they were to insist that practitioners treated them as if they'd earned the belt or, conversely, somehow prevented a legitimate holder of the belt from wearing one then you have a case for grievance.