Re:Overcomplexifying, Underdelivering
by ilaksh on Wednesday October 21, 2015 @04:01PM
(#10428228)
It makes sense to survey and try to think of ways to consolidate common functionality and data, but after a certain amount of that you need tackle modernization in small chunks, even though you will need a good way for systems to talk. And the business deal needs to be structured in small chunks too.
If you try to make a giant deal up front that is supposed to encompass all spending and tasks that many managers, engineers, or companies can think of, of course you are going to overrun. Or similarly trying to reproduce/refactor all of the efforts over several years of the predecessor teams of engineers and managers.
And another part of this is that people are bidding, which means you have to be in the ballpark of the other bids, and you probably need to be lower than the lowest bid, and everyone has an incentive to bid lower regardless of the actual scope because they have to make their bid attractive to have an opportunity to even actually examine the real requirements.
But its even harder because estimating even a lone software project is very difficult. Its hard to sell realistic budgets, since business people are often used to interacting with relatively simple to use software like Excel, where it might take a day to figure out the most complicated part of a spreadsheet for a certain purpose. By the way, don't underestimate the power and real value of spreadsheets to business people.
If you try to make a giant deal up front that is supposed to encompass all spending and tasks that many managers, engineers, or companies can think of, of course you are going to overrun. Or similarly trying to reproduce/refactor all of the efforts over several years of the predecessor teams of engineers and managers.
And another part of this is that people are bidding, which means you have to be in the ballpark of the other bids, and you probably need to be lower than the lowest bid, and everyone has an incentive to bid lower regardless of the actual scope because they have to make their bid attractive to have an opportunity to even actually examine the real requirements.
But its even harder because estimating even a lone software project is very difficult. Its hard to sell realistic budgets, since business people are often used to interacting with relatively simple to use software like Excel, where it might take a day to figure out the most complicated part of a spreadsheet for a certain purpose. By the way, don't underestimate the power and real value of spreadsheets to business people.