Re:Programmers Need To Learn Statistics Or I Will Kill Them All
by alain94040 on Saturday January 09, 2010 @10:38PM
(#1042577)
If you care only about 99.9% of your requests being on time, it means that one in a 1000 can time-out and die
Your argument is mathematically correct, but from an engineering point of view, doesn't make sense.
Of course in theory a system which responds 99.9% of the time means that it's possible for 1 of 1000 requests to die horribly. But we are engineers. If I achieve 99.99% of my target, it means that it's highly likely that that one request will also behave with pretty good performance, but I can't be sure that it will be 100ms. It might be 150ms. Or 200ms. But as an engineer, I claim that I am not concerned and don't care about knowing precisely that number.
I think this is what the author of the original article misses completely: he is applying advanced math and refuses to consider that engineering tradeoffs are practical. Of course in theory they aren't. But in practice they are.
Your argument is mathematically correct, but from an engineering point of view, doesn't make sense.
Of course in theory a system which responds 99.9% of the time means that it's possible for 1 of 1000 requests to die horribly. But we are engineers. If I achieve 99.99% of my target, it means that it's highly likely that that one request will also behave with pretty good performance, but I can't be sure that it will be 100ms. It might be 150ms. Or 200ms. But as an engineer, I claim that I am not concerned and don't care about knowing precisely that number.
I think this is what the author of the original article misses completely: he is applying advanced math and refuses to consider that engineering tradeoffs are practical. Of course in theory they aren't. But in practice they are.