News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BoringSSL by zaroth on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @09:40PM (#10423049)
It's just "because entropy used to be really difficult!" We now have relatively simple and proven algorithms (Yarrow, Fortuna) which can take 256-bits of entropy, and deliver effectively infinite streams of high quality entropy from that core without leaking any of the seed, or skewing the output. In such a system, pulling bits out of the core entropy bucket is counter-productive.

As djb says;

  Cryptographers are certainly not responsible for this superstitious
  nonsense. Think about this for a moment: whoever wrote the /dev/random
  manual page seems to simultaneously believe that

    (1) we can't figure out how to deterministically expand one 256-bit
    /dev/random output into an endless stream of unpredictable keys (this
    is what we need from urandom), but

    (2) we _can_ figure out how to use a single key to safely encrypt many
    messages (this is what we need from ssl, pgp, etc.).

  For a cryptographer this doesn't even pass the laugh test.

BSD and OS X are more modern than Linux in their choice of CS-PRNG; they used to use Yarrow, and then added Fortuna support in 2014 (behind a config flag) and will make it default in 11.0. Linux has used largely the same CS-PRNG for /dev/urandom since 1994, with some upgrades to their mixing function, to prevent DoS against /dev/random, and upgraded recently to include random bytes extracted from "RDRAM" provided by Intel CPUs.

I'm not sure why we haven't seen the underlying CS-PRNG switched wholesale to Fortuna in Linux. For example, they are still using a SHA-1 based output hash, which seems like it might be time for that to go.

The higher level take-away is that trying to avoid the modest code complexity of the CS-PRNG by going directly to /dev/random is more likely to lead to an exploitable catastrophic failure than sticking with /dev/urandom.

There are no comments on this comment yet.