People can be wrong that:
a) The school should have instantly made Ahmed a saint on seeing his device
while still being correct that:
b) This never should have escalated to arrest.
Both a) and b) speak to the question of whether the school reacted poorly.
The question is: what social forces do we blame in this case? Paranoid gun hating liberals? Or bigoted Muslim-hating conservatives? The media cast blame solidly on the latter group. But I think the facts better support blaming the former group.
Certainly the zero-tolerance policy of this and other districts cannot be effective, and certainly they aren't preventing any school shootings -- zero tolerance policies reached their apex in the years after columbine, but there are still shootings on a regular basis. So a liberal that pushes a zero-tolerance policy is certainly not doing it from the rational, evidence-based center of their kind soul.
I think that's really stupid and that people are too sensitive about school shootings, but that's an entirely different argument.