News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Little Gear That Could Reshape the Jet Engine by Animats on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:15PM (#10415830)
There's a long negative history of high-speed gearing. Jet engines have one big rotating unit, and that basic simplicity is good for reliability. Turboprops have a gearbox, and fragile, high-maintenance gearboxes are a long-standing problem with turboprops. Adding a gearbox without reducing reliability is a major achievement.
Re:A Little Gear That Could Reshape the Jet Engine by iammaxus on Monday October 19, 2015 @08:21PM (#10416713)
High-speed gearing is indeed very difficult, but jet engines already typically have two separate, concentric rotating units (spools: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbofan#Basic_two_spool). Also, as the article mentions, turboprops (essentially jet engines connected to a propeller) already commonly use gearing. I guess you can think of it as a turboprop with a duct.

The reality is probably just that this is a solvable problem that just wasn't worth the work while there were easier efficiency gains to be had.

Re:A Little Gear That Could Reshape the Jet Engine by fancyketchup on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @02:18AM (#10417709)
> High-speed gearing is indeed very difficult, but jet engines already typically have two separate, concentric rotating units [...]

Yes, everyone knows that, but the spools are not connected by a set of gears as they are in the P&W's new engine.

> Also, as the article mentions, turboprops (essentially jet engines connected to a propeller) already commonly use gearing. I guess you can think of it as a turboprop with a duct.

The new engine is ALSO unlike most installations of turboprop engines in that the fan is driven by the power spool, not a free turbine. The free turbine (in turboprops that have them), which powers the reduction gears for the propeller, runs at a much lower speed than the power turbine.