News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Saturday January 09, 2010 @09:36AM (#1041489)
Opposite - having kids IMHO keeps you young, and in touch with your playful side.

One of the reasons I had kids early was to do that. I didn't want to be one of those old parents who has already "grown up" and lost all touch with fun.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by theBobMcCormick on Saturday January 09, 2010 @10:56PM (#1042600)
I think it has for me. At least, it's given me an excuse to keep in touch with my inner child. My sons and I play with lego's together. Watch cartoons and kids shows (I love What's New Scooby Doo), etc.

Of course, I'm not sure what's gonna happen with all that as they get older. :-( Maybe I'll really become an old man then.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by nfnaaron on Saturday January 09, 2010 @09:52AM (#1041504)
"having kids IMHO keeps you young, and in touch with your playful side."

Agreed, and since I had my kid later, I'm still goofy and playful. I think if he was years gone I'd be guarding my lawn with razor wire and proximity sensors.j

Children give you the chance to appreciate childhood.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by mlLK on Saturday January 09, 2010 @10:00AM (#1041509)
I think 'old parents' losing all touch with fun is an unfair stereotype, but I think I understand where you're coming from by narrowing the generational/cultural divide between you and your son or daughter you're minimizing the difference in how you communicate and think.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Saturday January 09, 2010 @10:42AM (#1041552)
Right. I think it's certainly possible to keep that fun/childish side going, and stay in touch with culture etc without having kids around, but it's much harder.

I see what you're saying... I didn't mean that old parent wouldn't be fun, but it's likely to be a different type of fun. One that may be alien to kids.

We have several stages of our lives and I thing overlapping with your kids makes it so you can enjoy more of the same things together.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by traveler on Saturday January 09, 2010 @09:49AM (#1041502)
> having kids IMHO keeps you young

Let me guess, you think having a mortgage keeps you thinking independently and on your toes, too?

It's amazing the conclusions people will arrive at to rationalize their fucked up thinking.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Saturday January 09, 2010 @09:57AM (#1041508)
I'm not seeing the parallel there.

Having a mortgage is pretty much the most efficient way to save money for the future. But I've no idea why that's related to having kids.

And what's fucked up about having kids young in life? It makes a ton of sense when you think about it.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by Retric on Saturday January 09, 2010 @11:34AM (#1041596)
The problem with a mortgage is it tends to increase consumption. Most people are fine renting a fairly small apartment relative to their needs, but as soon as they are buying a place they start thinking about having an extra rooms just in case etc.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Saturday January 09, 2010 @11:39AM (#1041603)
I don't think that's the case. Mortgage is just borrowing against your future worth. If some people over estimate that then it's their own problem.

The problem is usually silly people borrowing far more than they can afford, and lenders trying to push people into borrowing more than they can afford. But that's not a problem with mortgages per se.

Renting is ok if you like throwing money away, or need to move often.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by theBobMcCormick on Saturday January 09, 2010 @11:01PM (#1042610)
I don't understand the throwing money away idea about renting. Are you anticipation appreciation (good luck for the foreseeable future)? Is it the home mortgage deduction you're so excited about? For most people, unless they're sure they're gonna be in their home for a long time (10+ years maybe?) I'm not sure how purchasing is worse than renting.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Sunday January 10, 2010 @04:36AM (#1042881)
In the UK house prices have risen well. And personally I like staying the same place for at least 5 years.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by theBobMcCormick on Sunday January 10, 2010 @03:14PM (#1043571)
I think a desire/plan to stay in one place for an extended period of time is a good reason to purchase a home. The best reason really. But I think if you're pretty uncertain about whether you'll want to spend 10+ years in 1 house it makes more sense to rent. And I really don't understand so many people have bought into this meme that renting is "throwing money away". The facts just don't seem to support that conclusion.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by Retric on Saturday January 09, 2010 @03:51PM (#1041965)
It's not just a question of needing to move often as much as benefiting from being able to move often. I walk to work and save a lot of time and money by doing so. But, I was willing to take a job with an hour+ commute because I knew I could quickly move there.

PS: The cost of renting tends to balance with the costs of buying a home (including transaction and maintenance costs etc) such that it's rare for one to win out over the other in a healthy housing market. I do spend a lot of money living in this area, but I also invest a lot more money than I could if I was trying to buy in the area even with a long commute. Even with the huge drop in housing costs buying in this area is extremely expensive in large part due to the number of people renting their houses / condo's.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by notauser on Saturday January 09, 2010 @12:14PM (#1041642)
In the UK average rental yields are under 5%, which means that on average over time renting is cheaper than servicing mortgage debt.

There are a lot of other factors that make a difference though, especially related to personal financial discipline, over-buying and tax incentives. Any of those can push things one way or the other.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Saturday January 09, 2010 @12:27PM (#1041666)
>> "In the UK average rental yields are under 5%, which means that on average over time renting is cheaper than servicing mortgage debt."

If you're paying over 5% for a mortgage you're doing something seriously wrong. Hell - if you're paying more than 2% you've been had.

And the other tiny point is that at the end of your mortgage, you own the house and can cash it in. If you have the option to buy, buying is always the sane choice.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by notauser on Saturday January 09, 2010 @12:48PM (#1041696)
Interest rates are unusually low at the moment, they more often hover between 4-6% and have been as high as 8% (and this is the base rate - most people pay more than this, especially for fixed rate deals).

In the long run owning your house may or may not work out to be more profitable than keeping the difference between rent and mortgage payments (plus maintenance plus taxes plus other fees) but it's not always the case.

This is especially true if the gap between the mortgage payment (plus costs and fees) and rent is well invested. At the moment countering the low cost of borrowing is the fact that equities are also very cheap. Every pound invested in the FTSE 250 in mid 2009 was a great buy, more than compensating for the low mortgage rate.

In the end buying vs renting is mostly a personal decision rather than an economic one.

EDIT: Graph of the UK base rate back to '97 - most people pay 2-4% above the interbank rate listed here. http://www.housepricecrash.co.uk/graphs-base-rate-uk.php

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Saturday January 09, 2010 @01:18PM (#1041730)
>> "This is especially true if the gap between the mortgage payment (plus costs and fees) and rent is well invested."

Firstly, there often isn't a gap, or it's negative - mortgage payments are less than rental payments.

Secondly, you'd be hard pressed to find a better paying investment than property.

House prices always increase in the long term. It's an investment. You buy a property, then a few years later can sell it for quite a bit more than you paid. As long as it's a property that is attractive people will always want it.

Personally I find the economics extremely clear cut. Mortgage payments here are comparable to rental payments, if not lower. So you can either give the money to a landlord and get nothing in return, or you can give it to a bank, pay off the balance (Long terms savings), and benefit when house prices increase if you sell it. Or of course just wait until mortgage is over and then live there rent free for the rest of your life.

I've never understood why the economics are even debated online like this :/

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by notauser on Saturday January 09, 2010 @08:04PM (#1042372)
Because, I'm afraid, your assumptions are flawed.

You are failing to account for the capital built up in the property which is only returning 5% (on average), whilst it could be earning a (historical) average of 12% elsewhere. (The average index fund growth.)

You are also failing to account for maintenance costs, which are not cheap on a property of any size. Specific to the UK market you are also not calculating stamp duty and capital gains tax, which are either property specific or harder to minimize on property.

The reason that the economics are debated on-line is because:

- Rentals have hidden advantages (opportunity cost of invested capital).

- Housing has unhidden advantages (capital growth of the property).

- It's much harder to screw up a family-home-property based investment scheme.

Which means that people invariably don't correctly account for all of the variables.

If property investing were that clear cut then investment capital would buy up property until house prices had risen and rents had been depressed to remove the advantage! Markets seek an equilibrium.

EDIT: I should probably point out that I have in front of me the yield data for four cities at the moment and the average return on capital for all of them is 4.8% - you personally may have found a better deal, but that's just an anomaly. I'd probably buy something if I had children, but it has nothing to do with the value of the investment.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Sunday January 10, 2010 @06:43AM (#1042960)
>> "You are failing to account for the capital built up in the property which is only returning 5% (on average), whilst it could be earning a (historical) average of 12% elsewhere. (The average index fund growth.)"

Yes but with a mortgage you're effectively investing someone elses money (the banks). You get to invest a large amount of money into a pretty good return investment, with hardly any outlay from yourself.

If you were renting and putting the (maybe £100 a month max) difference into some investment, you'd make next to nothing on that. But with a mortgage, you're 'investing' the banks money as well as your own.

I've only bought 2 houses in my life (3rd one soon), but both were financially very good. Even in the current market.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by notauser on Sunday January 10, 2010 @09:33AM (#1043091)
If you have £100k of equity/capital in your house then on average (long term historical index investment) you would have made £864k investing over 20 years vs a historical average of £165k in a property.

(Here's a source for the 12% figure - http://www.finfacts.ie/stockperf.htm )

The money your borrow from a bank can (depending on relative cost) close or open the gap. If average return is 5% and the average cost of borrowing is 2% (over 20 years) then you would make an additional £80k per hundred thousand borrowed. However if the average mortgage rate is 8% then you would lose an additional £80k per hundred thousand borrowed. Capital growth will also add something - over the last 20 years it was about 100k per 100k invested/borrowed.

2% and 8% are both well within the historical mortgage rate trends. Renting helps reduce your exposure to this, whilst increasing your exposure elsewhere.

All calculations are pre-inflation.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by gdee on Saturday January 09, 2010 @10:38AM (#1041550)
You forgot an (IMHO|IMNSHO) or two in there I think.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by zackattack on Saturday January 09, 2010 @12:27PM (#1041667)
"traveler" is clearly biased (look at his username) but he makes a good point. Multiple studies have shown that having kids decreases your happiness and increases your stress. Having kids is a biological imperative and your justifications are mostly backwards rationalizations. I'm guilty of backwards-rationalizing as much as the next guy but it's helpful for consciousness if you're aware of the phenomenon and can be honest with yourself.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by BigZaphod on Saturday January 09, 2010 @01:21PM (#1041734)
I think it's disingenuous to use this kind of counter-argument to justify some people's almost unnatural hatred of children and the people who have and want them.

Backward rationalizations can be used to change your future ways of thinking. In other words, if you feel that the stress of having a child will be well worth it, then you'll tell yourself that over and over while you're stressed. It will become true to you and the perception and emotions of a stress event changes.

This kind of reverse thinking is how we grow. Touch a hot stove, burn yourself, and cry about it. Next time you won't want to touch the hot stove because it hurt last time. If you did a study of people who touched hot stoves just after the fact, I'm sure you'd find that touching a hot stove reduces happiness and increases stress levels. However if you wait long enough, this lesson of stoves==hot results in decades of NOT touching hot stoves and NOT getting burned by them. A study of that should reveal that by touching a hot stove once, you've gained a lifetime absence (aside from accidents) of the stress and unhappiness associated with touching a hot stove. Suddenly the one time you burned yourself seems to have been worth the pain.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by zackattack on Sunday January 10, 2010 @10:08AM (#1043132)
So the "one time" you have kids causes an immediate intense amount of pain, but for every moment thereafter, it's worth it?

No. Having kids is a strenuous process that takes 18+ years.

Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by BigZaphod on Sunday January 10, 2010 @12:04PM (#1043291)
Do you have kids? I do. If it's all pain, then you're doing it wrong.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by zackattack on Sunday January 10, 2010 @08:28PM (#1044077)
Perhaps biased bc I come from a dysfunctional family.
Re:Things I'm not allowed to do anymore by axod on Saturday January 09, 2010 @12:46PM (#1041694)
It depends on what sort of person you are. I couldn't live without having kids. It's what 'the point' is for me. Not to mention the enormous gratification in helping to shape some new human beings and watch them grow into their own personalities.

Startups also massively increase your stress and likely decrease happiness for most, but we still do them.