News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Monday October 19, 2015 @10:43AM (#10413195)
When black people do it they're seen as aggressive.

Aggressive or "Angry". It takes a bit of conversational judo to avoid such an appearance. I'm a big black guy. (6'2", 255 pounds) It rarely goes well for men like me if we're perceived as angry or aggressive.

When someone starts talking over me, I become not only quiet but still. As close to motionless as possible. I even slow down my rate of blinking. Remaining silent and motionless forces all attention in the room onto the person who is speaking.

It makes them and anyone else in the room acutely aware that this person just cut you off and has breached standard etiquette. At that point, the pressure to be polite usually kicks in "Oh, I'm sorry. You were saying?"

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by boothead on Monday October 19, 2015 @11:19AM (#10413434)
This is a really great communication hack! It's a pretty poor comment on society at large that you've had to mitigate your communication based purely on how people judge your appearance, but thank you for sharing it.
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Monday October 19, 2015 @12:48PM (#10414054)
If one is aware of the biases of others, they can be used to one's advantage.

This happened a little over 20 years ago.

I was shopping at the mall, near Christmas and the place was packed. There were some really long lines and I said to my friend "Watch this", then walked over to some items that were near the item that I wanted to buy. I started picking up, examining and putting back small items that were on the shelf. I was sure to do it in a way that showed I was putting each item back in its original position before moving on to the next one.

In under 90 seconds, a salesperson approached me and asked if I needed help. I said "Yes, I'd like to buy this" and reached for the item I wanted. He proceeded to take the item, carry it to an unused register, ring me up and complete the sale. I was out of the story in 5 minutes while the other people in line had barely moved.

My friend (who is white) looked at me and asked "What just happened there?" and I explained to him that I was taking advantage of racist perceptions to improve my own shopping experience.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by tomp on Monday October 19, 2015 @02:36PM (#10414690)
Can you explain to me what racist perceptions that were, and why you got what you wanted? I don't have experience that would help me decode that situation...
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by DanBC on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:23PM (#10415039)
Black people are seen as all being thieves. The shop keep assumes thief, goes to investigate, and is subverted to beat the queue.

There's a relevant recent article on HN:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10386387

http://m.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/racial-profiling-via-nex...

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by tomp on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:34PM (#10415125)
Yes, I've assumed as much, but I don't understand why would that make the assistant help him? To get him out of the store quicker?

Also, why was he doing what he was (taking stuff, looking at it, putting it back where it was)?

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:50PM (#10415231)
I didn't understand all of this at the time, I just knew that it worked. Later, when I worked in retail, I learned why.

Retail employees aren't supposed to stop shoplifters. They are expected to take opportunities to turn potential shoplifting incidents into sales.

I used the perception that the salesperson had of me as a young black male to my advantage. I picked things up and was conspicuous about putting them back in the exact same place to draw attention to myself. I was behaving in an incongruous manner, not necessarily a suspicious one. Basically, I was doing something different than the other people there and that got someone's attention. I thought that they'd assume I was looking to shoplift and someone would come over to "help" me while other customers were still waiting. I was right. Ringing me up right then and there guaranteed that the sale took place instead of sending me off to wait in line where I might just walk out.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by tomp on Monday October 19, 2015 @04:12PM (#10415376)
Brilliant.
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by pbhjpbhj on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:49PM (#10416043)
>I picked things up and was conspicuous about putting them back in the exact same place to draw attention to myself. I was behaving in an incongruous manner, not necessarily a suspicious one. //

Based on your description you behaved in a suspicious manner.

People don't browse like that in general but shoplifters do - you didn't behave like a "young black male" [ie like any random person] you behaved like a person that the security guards have seen stealing things before, you pick up lots of items, look around a lot, have an accomplice to act as lookout/provide distraction/carry-goods. Small items are great as you can pick two, palm one and then make a show of replacing the other. Similarly in an area with high value goods a shoplifter will "browse" lots of items as they're waiting for their moment whilst a shopper, particularly getting a large-ticket item, will go straight for the item as that's why they came.

Now it might be that they noticed that behaviour initially because you were profiled as suspect based on racial prejudice, but as soon as you enact the behaviour then the response was response to shoplifter behaviour rather than racial prejudice.

I'd be interested if anyone knows about use of CV to flag potential shoplifters based on standard behaviours?? Seems the tech is there to do that.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Monday October 19, 2015 @06:17PM (#10416182)
It's my contention that my demographic information is why my behavior was regarded as suspicious.

Had I been a middle aged white guy, it would have been seen as the behavior of an interested customer.

To just put it out in the open, this was a Radio Shack. I have been going to Radio Shacks since I was about 7 years old and looking through all of the hobby electronics. Over the years, I discovered that I could get the attention and assistance of a salesperson at will.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by pbhjpbhj on Monday October 19, 2015 @06:32PM (#10416262)
Doesn't the fact you can get the attention at will disprove your hypothesis? It's the behaviour that gets the attention, otherwise you wouldn't be in control. If it weren't the behaviour then you'd get approached as often when you don't do as when you do.

As I said before it could be that you get observed more because of your demographic, but if you can perform a behaviour that gets direct attention then it's not your race or other aspects of your appearance that's causing the staff action.

Just stand where you are and start swearing loudly will work too, you'll get a member of staff, they'll say "can I help you" - it's the usual attempt in a commercial environment to be non-confrontational when really one means "you look suspicious, why are you here" - you then say "please ring this up for me". Chances are they see that will get you out of the store ASAP, which would be their intention during the approach.

I work in a store, it's really obvious when people don't follow standard purchasing/enquiry patterns.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @01:16AM (#10417550)
Doesn't the fact you can get the attention at will disprove your hypothesis?

Not at all. What would be perceived as customer interest as a non-minority customer is perceived as suspicious as a minority customer.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @08:56AM (#10418822)
So you consider the behaviour to be normal? It's very difficult to behave normally when focussing on a particular behaviour, most people are not very good actors IME.

Would be interested if you can recreate this as a demonstration; also a video showing the behaviour would be great, I'd certainly attempt a duplicate.

>What would be perceived as customer interest as a non-minority customer is perceived as suspicious as a minority customer. //

I perceive problems with this line of thinking - for example any young solo male at the store I work at is suspicious. Does that mean I'm ageist and sexist? No, just that this demographic is contrary to the normal use of our services; moreover the only major theft we've had was by someone in this demographic.

We might fail to notice someone else stealing because our attention is elsewhere whilst with people in that demographic our attention will be much more tightly focussed; according to our records this has never happened however.

In your opinion is it wrong for us to behave in this way?

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:55AM (#10419550)
So you consider the behaviour to be normal?

Depending on how you define "normal". If you mean acting like everyone else, then absolutely not. My goal was to be incongruous.

If you mean acting calmly and naturally, then yes. I wasn't nervous because I knew that I wasn't doing anything wrong. I wasn't doing anything that would get me in trouble.

We might fail to notice someone else stealing because our attention is elsewhere whilst with people in that demographic our attention will be much more tightly focussed; according to our records this has never happened however.

If you are watching the young males, how can you be sure? What kind of inventory shrinkage do you have?

In your opinion is it wrong for us to behave in this way?

We all have our biases. Whether or not it's wrong is debatable but if you miss a shoplifter because you were focusing your attention on the wrong person, that is your fault.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by BurningFrog on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:29PM (#10415920)
He deliberately looked like a shop lifter, so someone came over and got him quickly out of the store, which made both of them feel better.
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by harryjo on Monday October 19, 2015 @02:39PM (#10414707)
Putting the item exactly back in place, is that to increase the clerk's suspicion of shoplifting, or defend against accusations of it?
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:34PM (#10415121)
To draw attention to myself.

If the norm is for people to put it back close to the same spot, I make sure to do it precisely, because it's incongruous and will draw attention.

My goal was to make them think "What's that guy doing?" as opposed to "I think that guy is trying to seal something."

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by pbhjpbhj on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:51PM (#10416052)
You can pick 2 items if they're small, put one back to attempt to appear like you didn't take anything; works with clothing too. Suspicious behaviour looks suspicious.
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by boothead on Monday October 19, 2015 @01:16PM (#10414249)
That is truly amazing! Deren Brown would approve!
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by harryjo on Monday October 19, 2015 @02:35PM (#10414678)
It's not fair that you have to do this; yet I'm glad you have found a way to mitigate the cost of unfair treatment, and I hope people will curtail their biases in future.

About the not-blinking, though --- that seems like staring, which I would guess would get lumped in with the body language that gets called aggressive. (I'd guess that blinking more makes you look surprised and wounded, which is the effect you are going for in this scenario)

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @01:09AM (#10417532)
I still blink but I do it at a slower rate and I deliberately slow the blinks.

I suppose it's more art than science to not appear to be staring but to be blinking less often.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by Kluny on Monday October 19, 2015 @12:34PM (#10413956)
How often do you do that? Does it work consistently? I'd like to try it and see if it works - I have a problem where when I'm at dinner with my family, the two old men in the room (my dad and uncle) will shout over the other three people at the table, excluding us from the conversation. I wonder if this technique would work, but I have the feeling they wouldn't even notice.
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by harryjo on Monday October 19, 2015 @02:40PM (#10414715)
In an argument, a common technique when someone yells at you is to lower your own voice. It makes the other person angrier and look stupider.
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by pbhjpbhj on Monday October 19, 2015 @05:55PM (#10416081)
I thought the point was to demonstrate you're not being violently aggressive [with your voice at least] and to get the person to have to pay closer attention, ie move in, at which point they risk escalating too much if they continue being very loud.

This to me is a defusing technique rather than an attempt to increase the other persons anger and to humiliate them.

Guess it depends on what you want to get out of the situation: you could adopt a quiet voice and non-threatening demeanour but be highly offensive with your language and probably achieve the ends you mention quite well.

Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by LordKano on Monday October 19, 2015 @12:49PM (#10414063)
It doesn't happen often and consequently, I don't have to do it often. I doubt that it would work on family.
Re:How Can We Achieve Age Diversity in Silicon Valley? by zo1 on Monday October 19, 2015 @09:29PM (#10416910)
I do the same thing. There really isn't any point escalating the situation when someone is clearly being out of line and unfairly interrupting you. It almost always devolves into a shouting match. And then drama ensues, and someone has to mediate to resolve, and so on, etc.

I've also seen others that react in different ways. Some of them react a little too-hastily to being interrupted with some sort of hostile comment (even after doing it others), and don't adapt to the situation. There are some discussions that are lively and very back and forth.

Really, at the end of the day we're all just there to solve problems with good solutions. If you have a good idea, as long as no one is actively blocking/ignoring it, it needs to be considered.