News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by koevet on Saturday January 09, 2010 @05:26AM (#1041313)
Naturally I was implying some sort of legit investment, such as goods that can be mass produced and sold to the world. It may sound cynical, but a fascination indeed exists with products coming from troubled places. Furthermore, there is a whole commercial philosophy behind supporting developing countries: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_trade
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by lsb on Saturday January 09, 2010 @08:00AM (#1041430)
Fair Trade keeps the Triangle Trade alive and well.

If you want to change things and help developing nations, make sure those developing nations have added most of the value.

For example, you can buy fair trade chocolate bars, with beans bought from Ecuador at a "fair" price, whatever that means. But then the bars are made in Switzerland, or France, and the European country adds much of the value, and keeps much of the profit.

Kallari Rainforest Chocolate, for example, is a cooperative making chocolate, and they pick the beans in the lowlands and drive up to the mountains and turn them into bars, and then airmail it out.

If you want to make a difference, figure out where your money actually goes.

Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by w00pla on Saturday January 09, 2010 @08:17AM (#1041438)
Fair trade is a first World scam. What fair trade does is mandate the price of certain commodities.

This in effect negates the biggest advantage of developing countries (cheap labour) and allows the products to be manufactured in developed countries at a "fair" price.

Fair trade, along with agricultural subsidization is some of the most evil things that developed countries do.

Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by snan on Saturday January 09, 2010 @10:24AM (#1041534)
I wouldn’t be so quick in lumping these two (fair trade labeling vs agricultural subsidization) together. I agree that fairtrade has problems. However, I see merit to the idea to inform consumers about the background of certain products (information is vital to market economy, right?). Fairtrade certification doesn’t just mean “fair” prices but also some restrictions on slave labor, the right to unionize, and conservation of the environment and some other network externalities. Product labeling is a classic direct action tactic and I think it’s a great way to concisely provide information that would otherwise be obscure.

This is not a subsidy and it’s not a tariff. It’s (an attempt at) providing information.

Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by rthj on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @11:59PM (#1064098)
Ok, so a coop or factory in a "3rd world" country needs to pay around $5k to a European organization to get this certification for this Fairtrade thing. It seems to me this just continues the racist attitude North America and Europe have toward certain countries. I'm sure not every factory or coop in the "3rd world" takes advantage of its workers. Maybe the "3rd world" should come up with some type of similar program for U.S. farmers to prove they didn't exploit migrant farm workers. I won't even go into all the stupid problems that occur when you create an artificial floor price for a product.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by ilkhd2 on Saturday January 09, 2010 @06:59PM (#1042229)
Do not like it - do not buy, goddamnit. If you think that people who buy Fair Trade are stupid - no we are not, and we are doing for a reason - we do not feel good when consume something made by slaves. You can still shop for "free trade" stuff, nobody prevents you from doing that.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by whughes on Sunday January 10, 2010 @02:32AM (#1042799)
He didn't say you were just stupid, or that you were wasting your money. He said fair trade was evil. That means it's not so easy as saying "if you don't like it, don't buy it." Ignoring evil is not good, even if other people are doing the evil. "If you don't like murder, don't murder people" won't stop other people from committing murders. You're free to have your own opinion on whether fair trade actually is evil, but please address his point rather than ignoring it.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by eru on Sunday January 10, 2010 @01:40PM (#1043425)
With a bit of goodwill, you can read the ilkhd's comment as: If all participants are in there voluntarily, it can't be evil; and you are free to ignore it.

I do not like the `fairtrade' stuff for the same reasons as w00pla, but since nobody's forced to participate (as opposed to agricultural subsidies and tariffs), I do not mind other people engaging in this.

Fair trade is free trade where people in the developed world choose to pay the produces to pay them for certain strange things. E.g. as a fairtrade producer you can not employ day labourers. (At least that's what I heard. But I do not remember the source.) And genetically modified plants are banned, too. (http://www.fairtrade.org.uk/includes/documents/cm_docs/2008/...)

I can image myself paying more for stuff that gets produced in nice working conditions and does not damage the environment. But I'd actually prefer to see more GM and I do not mind day labourers. Perhaps one could create an alternative to `fairtrade' where you can combine your own building blocks of stuff you want to pay extra for?

Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by snan on Friday January 15, 2010 @11:02AM (#1055112)
Right, even hough that’s a bit of a simplification.

It’s not necessarily “paying more”, looking at the clarified conditions as services (even though of course there’s overhead, and possibility of corruption, in the labeling and certification process).

Imaging some item, let’s say jeans. You can get just jeans from company A, with an unknown profit margin or middlemen, or you can get jeans from company B together with information and conditions on production.

If these conditions were a service you were charged explicitly for, of course the company B jeans would be more expensive than the ones from company A. That’s not necessarily the case, however, since there might be unknown expenses for the consumer involved with company A (like, say, higher profit margins).

Or, for that matter, the jeans from company A could be every bit as “fairly” produced, just you don’t know about it. Nothing says that the labeled (“B” in the example) ones would be more expensive, disregarding the labelling/certification overhead.

Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by radu_floricica on Saturday January 09, 2010 @09:12AM (#1041471)
God, I hate this kind of marketing. Until I read this link if anyone had asked me I'd say very convinced that I'm in favor of fair trade. I guess these days you have to be more careful what you support.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by ilkhd2 on Saturday January 09, 2010 @05:35AM (#1041318)
If you like products, coming from troubled places I'd recommend to look at American products. USA is a very troubled country. Great inequality, corruption, pollution, crime, wars. Lack of labor law. Infrastructure is falling apart. There is chance the products are by slaves somewher in midwestern states.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by koevet on Saturday January 09, 2010 @05:47AM (#1041326)
Sounds like you have never laid a foot on a troubled place.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by ilkhd2 on Saturday January 09, 2010 @06:01AM (#1041340)
Sounds like somebody have never been outside downtown San Francisco/Seattle/or whatever and saw real life in USA. I lived in Florida for couple of years, and I never saw (anywhere I had a chance to live) such grotesque contrast between poverty in the inside cities and absurd richness on the oceanfront.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by mtts on Saturday January 09, 2010 @07:31AM (#1041404)
If you think that is in any way comparable to a country like North Korea (essentially one huge prison camp) or countries in Africa such as Guinee or Congo where maybe a hundred or so people are fabulously wealthy and the rest of the population doesn't have nearly enough to eat, your sense of perspective is, I would say, seriously out of whack.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by m_eiman on Saturday January 09, 2010 @02:37PM (#1041864)
Not to mention that little thing called "war".
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by ilkhd2 on Saturday January 09, 2010 @07:09PM (#1042256)
... with Middle East, that already cost 3*10^12 $??
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by m_eiman on Monday January 11, 2010 @01:21AM (#1044492)
I'd say that that war is a lot worse in Middle East than it is in the US. Not speaking from personal experience, but having a $5000 dollar bomb dropped on you and/or your relatives seems like it'd be worse than paying for it.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by eru on Sunday January 10, 2010 @01:47PM (#1043436)
And the US is still doing fine. They can waste a lot more resources before it's going to be as bad as in some other places.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by ilkhd2 on Saturday January 09, 2010 @07:08PM (#1042251)
You know what, as I mentioned in other posts - inequality in USA is already as bad as in Africa and is rapidly approaching South American's numbers. Of course bottom line is not as bad as in Africa, but quality of life for poors is already totaly incomparable with Europe. So from the point of view of Africans or Brazilians - yes USA is not that bad. From Canadian/European point view - USA is rather troubled place.
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by eru on Sunday January 10, 2010 @01:49PM (#1043439)
Thanks for giving a bit more background and some nuances. If you were fleshing this out a some more (and give more sources), this could get interesting.

By the way, how do you account for the number of people willing to emigrate to the US, if it's such a bad place?

Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by ilkhd2 on Sunday January 10, 2010 @05:00PM (#1043741)
What kind of numbers you want? GINI (inequality index)?: ok http://mapscroll.blogspot.com/2009/04/is-us-becoming-third-w... That the poors are doing here worse than anywhere else in developed world: obvious from the GINI.

How do I account number of people willing to immigrate: 1. It is way,way easier to move to USA, than anywhere else in developed world. 2. Proximity of Latin American/Carribean countries, which are verrry bad. And you do not need an expensive ticket from Haiti for example. Just find whatever floating and have a free ride.

Now how you account for that: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/03/02/the-real-high-tech-... ?

Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by markbao on Saturday January 09, 2010 @06:00PM (#1042139)
Florida? Are you serious?
Re:Swedish startup selling North Korean jeans by ilkhd2 on Saturday January 09, 2010 @07:02PM (#1042236)
yes, why? Have ever been to west palm beach, and then palm beach itself? Difference is obvious. I am not even talking about Miami beach and Miami.