Re:Reader macros in Common Lisp
by wtbob on Monday October 19, 2015 @06:02AM
(#10411998)
The author does address that in the article:
> However with great power comes great responsibility, so you should learn to use them with great care. For example, while a JSON reader was a good exercise in understanding reader macros, I would never use it in real world for the simple reason that easier alternatives already exist.
and:
> There is a saying that goes along these lines: where a function will do, don't use a macro. A corollary for reader macros could be: where a sexp will do, don't use a reader macro. Yes, it might be a subjective call, but think twice before using a reader macro.
The second is particularly spot-on: sometimes you need a reader macro, but often you don't. But when you do…you do.
> However with great power comes great responsibility, so you should learn to use them with great care. For example, while a JSON reader was a good exercise in understanding reader macros, I would never use it in real world for the simple reason that easier alternatives already exist.
and:
> There is a saying that goes along these lines: where a function will do, don't use a macro. A corollary for reader macros could be: where a sexp will do, don't use a reader macro. Yes, it might be a subjective call, but think twice before using a reader macro.
The second is particularly spot-on: sometimes you need a reader macro, but often you don't. But when you do…you do.