Re:Get Free Access to Pay-Walled Content with a Simple Googl...
by patio11 on Saturday January 09, 2010 @01:14AM
(#1041112)
This is abusing Google's monopoly bargaining power to steal from content creators. For shame.
(Here's the bargain: "You will implement First Click Free or you will vanish from our search results, to be replaced by the people who copy/paste your articles and put AdSense on them.")
Re:Get Free Access to Pay-Walled Content with a Simple Googl...
by sorbus on Saturday January 09, 2010 @01:55AM
(#1041151)
They could always make only a portion of their article available - say, the first paragraph or two. Some sites do this for non-paying users. Admittedly, the content-free nature of such a choice might adversely effect their standing.
Or implement a server-side thing to check if the requester is a googlebot, and if so give them the entire page, or if not ask them to register/pay. Might raise some issues with Google's cache, but that could probably be worked around (does Google allow sites to opt-out of that? Does that influence their positioning?)
EDIT: Having noticed that Google refers to this as cloaking, and dislikes it rather extremely, I'm having a bit of trouble figuring out what would work better. So, it does seem like a bit of an issue ...
(Here's the bargain: "You will implement First Click Free or you will vanish from our search results, to be replaced by the people who copy/paste your articles and put AdSense on them.")
Or implement a server-side thing to check if the requester is a googlebot, and if so give them the entire page, or if not ask them to register/pay. Might raise some issues with Google's cache, but that could probably be worked around (does Google allow sites to opt-out of that? Does that influence their positioning?)
EDIT: Having noticed that Google refers to this as cloaking, and dislikes it rather extremely, I'm having a bit of trouble figuring out what would work better. So, it does seem like a bit of an issue ...