News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Layoffs and Loyalty in a Liquid Valley by ChuckMcM on Sunday October 18, 2015 @03:44PM (#10409485)
This is a pretty straight call on things. Nobody likes getting laid off, even if they had the day before been wishing they would get laid off. It feels wrong, it feels personal, and it feels bad.

That said, it forces you to look at new opportunities and that can be a good thing. There was a person I knew at Sun who was layed off and that forced them to find a new job and they landed at a company that then went public and they made several million dollars. It really struck me how what seemed like something horrible for them really was the key to their future success.

The key for me was realizing that different people, in different situations, respond very differently to the folks around them. I've seen it work both ways where a "star" from Company A was recruited to work at the company I was working at and they flamed out miserably, and I've seen people that were very unproductive get layed off an blossom in a new environment into superstars.

I wish sometimes someone would do a long duration study of folks in the bay area to quantify the expected value of staying or leaving. My instinct tells me that the smart ones leave, the "loyal" ones pay a price for their loyalty that they don't expect.

Re:Layoffs and Loyalty in a Liquid Valley by gopalv on Sunday October 18, 2015 @05:02PM (#10409774)
> My instinct tells me that the smart ones leave, the "loyal" ones pay a price for their loyalty that they don't expect.

The opportunities that come up for a "smart" person is many-fold for the ones who're not acknowledged as smart - the difference in productivity might be minimal, but the label can be sticky purely due to narcissism.

Don't get me wrong. Self belief is an important part of signing up for a challenge that is bigger than anything you've done before - instead of being given a new badge & the same job elsewhere.

Then, there's the trouble with the signaling of "loyalty".

Not looking for another job is too easy to qualify as loyalty. But that's what mostly gets put up as being loyal, which is fairly low-bar for anyone.

Now, the trouble is removing the "just not looking" confounding factor from a proper study - relying on self-reporting for that is going to produce bias.

Loyalty as a word has come to mean a pseudo-virtue which is papered over the actual rational decision to stick with what you've got, considering all the risks. And people who can't see opportunity over the horizon rarely get to better places.

The fact that people blossom when they get laid off takes away that illusion - there is no status quo bias or loss aversion to overcome. Immediately people are less risk averse to new roles, knock on more doors & grow.

Loyalty as practiced would mean acting in mutual benefit always - not sacrifice.

Re:Layoffs and Loyalty in a Liquid Valley by thrway2busy on Sunday October 18, 2015 @05:31PM (#10409873)
>This is a pretty straight call on things. Nobody likes getting laid off, even if they had the day before been wishing they would get laid off. It feels wrong, it feels personal, and it feels bad.

I can't subscribe to this generalization. The context and manner are both extremely important.