News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: CloudScrape – Cloud-based web scraping platform by chinathrow on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:43PM (#10409227)
Well, copyright does prohibit redistributing the scraped content. And that is what all 3rd party content scraping services essentially do. That violates copyright law in quite a few countries. If you scrape with your own tools, own servers and use it only within your company, I would think it's a different legal matter.

No, it's not "by law" public, or could you cite a few laws for that, both US and EU. Would appreciate that.

Re:Show HN: CloudScrape – Cloud-based web scraping platform by kuschku on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:49PM (#10409250)
It is public because the HTTP standard defines it as public, and, if you claim to use this standard, its definitions apply to you (if you claim to support a standard, you have to accept that its definitions will be used in court against you)

HTTP directly says you should use authorization to make stuff non-public.

And third-party content scraping tools are NOT violating copyright law, as they do not redistribute it freely.

Otherwise services like Opera Turbo – which scrapes a website, removes cruft, compresses data, and sends it to your phone – would also break copyright law, and there is a nice exception for this case, under US law, it’s covered under fair use.

(Unless the scraping service makes your content accessible publicly – and even then, fair use applies usually, as in the case of pure archival like archive.org or archive.is)

Re:Show HN: CloudScrape – Cloud-based web scraping platform by chinathrow on Monday October 19, 2015 @03:34AM (#10411622)
You can have your content blocked from archive.org also by robots.txt - didn't check archive.is

Are you a lawyer? I am not - anyway, I can't really agree with that falls under fair use.

If I charge money to scrape someones site and then hand over the material in whatever form my customer uses - I am bound run into problems sooner or later.