Re:Ask HN: Technical interviews went amazing but HR is not a...
by DanBC on Sunday October 18, 2015 @12:54PM
(#10408794)
> HR team rejected them and some of the interesting reasons I found were -- they won't fit in a team setting, they are likely to change really soon and won't stick, and other reasons which I totally overlooked.
We don't know if HR was right or just guessing. Maybe you hadn't missed anything and those people would have been great hires?
Re:Ask HN: Technical interviews went amazing but HR is not a...
by Brajeshwar on Sunday October 18, 2015 @01:32PM
(#10408953)
May be. However, I've learnt to rather not hire and missed the opportunity than to hire and pray that it works out.
It is way harder to fire once hired, than spending a bit more time and hire someone else.
It has been a year every since I joined a friend's company which was acquired by Razorfish sometime back. I've been building and training a creative design and development (front-end) team. I might have interviewed north of 400 people so far in the last one year and I've so far built a strong team of 40+ people, missing my personal target of 50 by a few.
In that journey, there have been few instances where I really liked the person and would love to have them in the team. HR team rejected them and some of the interesting reasons I found were -- they won't fit in a team setting, they are likely to change really soon and won't stick, and other reasons which I totally overlooked.
Note: It is perfectly OK to get back to them and ask for the reason. Sometimes, things slips through the crack and candidates getting back to us really helped kicking back things into gear.