News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by aroch on Sunday October 18, 2015 @11:21AM (#10408434)
The opt-out doesn't really do anything: http://www.unrest.ca/google-analytics-opt-out-not-really
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hahainternet on Sunday October 18, 2015 @01:26PM (#10408933)
The article completely disagrees with you. Why did you post an article that doesn't say what you claim?
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:15PM (#10409115)
OPs linked article reinforces his point. The opt-out doesn't work- because they are not opting out and data is still being sent. (nevermind how that flag is set and Google is learning more about you despite your traffic no showing in webmaster reports)
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hahainternet on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:22PM (#10409137)
That is completely false. That is not what the linked article says.

edit: Two years ago the parent poster said this:

> Full disclosure: I've been working in analytics since 1999 and founded a web analytics business

And is currently posting what appear to be completely made up claims to this thread. No conflict of interest has been declared here.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:46PM (#10409238)
From OPs article: > the google analytics blocker does not stop your browser talking to google-analytics.com. Period.

That excerpt explains that it's not actually stopping any data from being sent. Thus it's not actually opting out of sending data.

Thanks for researching my comment history and establishing me as an authority. Not sure why you are saying that my insight is a conflict of interest here. I'm not promoting any products.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hahainternet on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:52PM (#10409268)
The website clearly states it does stop data being sent:

> Whats missing? Well, the original referrer. My google search. Well, it does appear that installing the GA.js blocker stops that info from going to google directly, however.

> Not sure why you are saying that my insight is a conflict of interest here

You are making false claims about a competitor without revealing that they are indeed a competitor nor that you have a long standing grudge against them.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @03:14PM (#10409368)
That data is being sent on the original load of the Javascript file. Please refer to this section of the article: "To summarize: When google opt-out is enabled. Google still collects." (you will see a list of all the data including the original referrer)

The part that you are quoting is for a different product by Google. "googleadservices.com"

>"You are making false claims about a competitor without revealing that they are indeed a competitor nor that you have a long standing grudge against them."

I am not making false claims. Please hold the heavy handedness until we have reached an understanding.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hackuser on Sunday October 18, 2015 @11:39AM (#10408503)
Thanks. That article was posted in 2010; does anyone know if it's still accurate?
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @12:03PM (#10408578)
Yes, it still works that way. (Downloads both the JavaScript file and the pixel)
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @11:28AM (#10408459)
Yes - good resource. All of Google's TOS/Privacy-Polcies are so full of vague and misleading legal speak (on purpose of course), I'm not surprised that OP was tricked.
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hahainternet on Sunday October 18, 2015 @01:28PM (#10408939)
> All of Google's TOS/Privacy-Polcies are so full of vague and misleading legal speak

Please provide 3 misleading examples.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by alain94040 on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:06PM (#10409074)
Everything is debatable of course, but pretty much on page 1 of Google's privacy page, I see:

We collect information to provide better services to all of our users – from figuring out basic stuff like which language you speak, to more complex things like which ads you’ll find most useful

I object to "ads you'll find most useful" being ok under the category "provide better services to our users". If you accept the premise that better ads are useful, then pretty much everything Google does is for your own good.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hahainternet on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:10PM (#10409096)
This is not misleading in any way, your only disagreement with it is on principle.

Even given that, I must say, the idea that better ads are not useful is probably fallacious

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:29PM (#10409161)
What are better ads? Are they ads that really connect with you? Do they change your behavior in some significant way? What makes ads better for the consumer? What makes ads better for the marketer? My answer is that what's good for the marketer is not good for the consumer. Google is optimizing for the marketer (getting better ROI). As long as consumers are told the ads are "unintrusive" they must be good too right? When marketers have a really strong ROI, they can get their ads out there and influence customer behavior. That type of influence is not good - and does not make it better for consumers.
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hahainternet on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:31PM (#10409172)
They explicitly state 'more useful'. That is the metric they are using, better ads are ads which are more useful.

For example. Until a day or two I did not know the 'MX Master' mouse existed. An advert for this would have been useful.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @03:03PM (#10409316)
Useful and obtrusive are not mutually exclusive. Is it useful to have only large companies with large ad budgets peddle a slight iteration to their product line as "the next best thing", while smaller companies with a really great (superior) product don't get the exposure. The smaller company would have lower margins because they invest much more in superior materials, QA, R&D, etc. Where the larger company has an advantage because they invest more of their margin on ads. Note: I have an "MX Performance" and I would not recommend that line of mice no matter what the ads originally said.
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by chestnut-tree on Sunday October 18, 2015 @03:22PM (#10409408)
"Please provide 3 misleading examples."

Google's privacy policy is not misleading but they omit some of the most important information you would expect to find in a privacy policy.

When you sign up for a Google account you give Google your name, date-of-birth (DOB), location and mobile phone number. This is some of your most private and personal details. If you're signed in to your Google account while you browse the web or use your Android phone (or you use the track-everything-you-do Chrome OS), then Google records your browing habits and activity against your account. In many cases, that also gives Google some very private and personal information about you. It's no exageration to say that they know more about your online habits than you know yourself.

Given that, Google omits in their privacy policy:

- how long they keep your activity data before it is erased. Is it 6 months? 12 months? Forever?

- whether they disassociate your identity from your browsing behaviour or web activity when they look at it (i.e is the data anonymised before Google's staff view it?)

- related to the above: who sees your data inside Google? Their Privacy Policy simply states "We restrict access to personal information to Google employees, contractors and agents who need to know that information in order to process it for us and who are subject to strict contractual confidentiality obligations." This is too vague in my opinion particularly when you consider the gargantuan volumes of data Google collects about you.

Let me put it another way: if I asked you for your name, DOB, mobile number and location and then recorded your online activity against that information, wouldn't you expect me to tell you who sees your data, whether that data is anonymised and how long I keep that data about you?

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hahainternet on Sunday October 18, 2015 @03:49PM (#10409505)
> When you sign up for a Google account you give Google your name, date-of-birth (DOB), location and mobile phone number. This is some of your most private and personal details

> Information you give us. For example, many of our services require you to sign up for a Google Account. When you do, we’ll ask for personal information, like your name, email address, telephone number or credit card to store with your account

They include that.

> Google records your browing habits and activity against your account

Also clearly explained in the Chrome privacy policy:

> If you sign in to Chrome browser, Chrome OS or an Android device that includes Chrome as a pre-installed application with your Google Account, this will enable the synchronisation feature. Google will store certain information, such as history, bookmarked URLs as well as an image and a sample of text from the bookmarked page, passwords and other settings, on Google's servers in association with your Google Account

> - how long they keep your activity data before it is erased. Is it 6 months? 12 months? Forever?

I agree this would be nice to have more details on but they do detail some of the complexities involved and refer you to specific services pages for more information.

> whether they disassociate your identity from your browsing behaviour or web activity when they look at it

This appears to be really part of your next question:

> related to the above: who sees your data inside Google? ... This is too vague in my opinion

Can you give me an example of a way this could be made less vague in an acceptable fashion? I'm struggling to think of a way they could give me relevant information.

> Let me put it another way: if I asked you for your name, DOB, mobile number and location and then recorded your online activity against that information, wouldn't you expect me to tell you who sees your data, whether that data is anonymised and how long I keep that data about you?

Personally I'd make the decision ahead of time. I do appreciate your point, but only a portion of your post is valid as they are quite clear on a couple of the points.

There's a large difference (imo) between 'misleading' and 'not thorough enough'.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @04:45PM (#10409718)
A couple concepts here: Associating data with your account: This is misleading, because the bulk of information about you isn't associated with your account. Rather, it's stored in other silos associated with a non-account identifier (consider this a way to make it easy to serve more targeted ads to people who don't even have a google account). This non-account identified data can be enriched by account data (when there are co-occurrences of account activity along with non-account identifiers).

The policy is vague and misleading because they should write: "We go to great efforts to track everything we possibly can about people's behavior on the web. We've configured algorithms to connect all the dots and make information about you (found in Service A, Service B, ...) useful. So useful that we can determine enough about you to tailor your online experience in order to influence your decisions when it comes to purchases, brand recognition, political leaning, etc." And follow it up with: "We do this even when the influence we have over you may harm your best interests, for the purpose improving ROI for advertisers" (Obviously this line is not conducive to the policy itself, but rather a blunt explanation of the effect of it which people are categorically unaware of)

The policies don't even explain that there is a difference between people seeing your data, and algorithms acting on your data. (Algorithms acting on your data are much more effective than when people do so. But that explanation in this case is lacking - it makes it seems like it's not all connected together, but in reality it is because of how databases work, and how disparate data sets can unique identify a person with enough data)

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:23PM (#10409140)
Are you looking for examples of entire policies or do you mean misleading sentences? Are you not sure why I find them misleading (based on OPs example, et. al.), or do you disagree and find them to not be misleading?
Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by hahainternet on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:27PM (#10409151)
Either / or. Google's policies are written in plain english and are extremely straightforward.

The reason I ask is that it sounded like an unfounded criticism made up by someone without adequate research.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by rchmura on Sunday October 18, 2015 @03:28PM (#10409426)
chestnut-tree, earlier in this thread wrote up some great examples.

No unfounded criticism here; lots of research in this area. I'm not sure why you feel it sounded that way.

Re:Google Analytics Opt-Out Browser Add-On by dandelion_lover on Sunday October 18, 2015 @01:23PM (#10408915)
>>I'm not surprised that OP was tricked

Actually, I wasn't. I know what to expect from Google, but I am not a developer and wanted to see the response from professionals about this plugin.