As a counter point, you could look at the success of Native American tribes that receive government grants or casino payouts, vs those that don't, such as the Lumbee Indians. http://www.nativetimes.com/index.php/business/features/2470-...
In the case of the Lumbee, there's still a strong sense of helping out folks that need it, but the help is at the discretion of the tribe, not a government (or casino). Furthermore, they've built that system without much federal help.
Note that I'm not arguing for an all or nothing approach here, I think it's reasonable for the federal government to help the tribe financially. I don't think it's reasonable to have the government give money directly to individuals in the tribe.
Well, in some tribes there is economic inequality due to local corruption. So this isn't really a one-size-fits-all solution. It works out well when the local government is actually working for the people (vs. just for itself + relatives).
Is this really true? Is the average Cherokee a criminal who spends 3 years in prison (google suggests prison costs a bit under $50k/year)?
"In total, 6,899,000 adults were under correctional supervision (probation, parole, jail, or prison) in 2013 – about 2.8% of adults (1 in 35) in the U.S. resident population."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_St...
You can't talk about "breakeven" without considering opportunity cost of not taking the choice - in this case, taxes and other returns that better outcomes would produce. It doesn't take much increase in outcomes to arrive with a benefit worth $80k over a whole lifetime.
Secondly, going on math alone, you're missing many variables: the (taxed) income of the free individual, hours volunteered, money donated, "positive influence" ripple effect, etc.
I see your point, but it’s important to note that the authors still haven’t established causation, but are planning a follow-up to do so. The authors aren’t making quite as strong of a claim as you’re making here -yet.
The immediate problem is that the costs of US courts and prisons are extremely high (1) and they are still growing quite rapidly. Jailing one criminal for three years costs over $100,000 (aside from the other social costs that other people have pointed out), which would cover a substantial amount of intervention.
Further, US prisons hold very large numbers of poor people, because poor people have the biggest motive to commit crimes (nothing to lose), and the least ability to pay for bail, lawyers or other treatments (eg for mental illness). I'll take correlation if it shows that interventions help poor children to avoid this fate.
(1) Quoting Wikipedia: "Judicial, police, and corrections costs totaled $212 billion in 2011 according to the U.S. Census Bureau. In 2007, around $74 billion was spent on corrections according to the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics."
"In 2014, among facilities operated by the Federal Bureau of Prisons, the average cost of incarceration for federal inmates in fiscal year 2014 was $30,619.85."
"In California in 2008, it cost the state an average of $47,102 a year to incarcerate an inmate in a state prison. From 2001 to 2009, the average annual cost increased by about $19,500."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_the_United_St...
Correlation is not causation. What, pray tell, is the direct link that causes a child's brain size to increase in relation to the parents' bank account? Perhaps the reason wealthier children are healthier is because their parents have discipline and work hard to provide a safe, healthy, stimulating environment for their children, which includes retaining steady gainful employment and using the proceeds from that employment to provide food, shelter, and education for the children. This will not magically happen among poor children if you give the parents some baseline income.
I'm not speaking in absolute terms; there is definitely some crossover with good parents who are down on their luck and bad parents who have way too much money. But boiling the problem down to "give poor people more money to fix kids' brain structures" is too lazy, and preaching this about like it's some fundamental righteous principle is highly distasteful.
I don't know; your argument seems to be actually the typical response, the kind of thing most people say when they see something that can be pattern-matched to "give money".
There are of course many non-material things that are important to growth of a children, but why dismiss this one so easy? Is it because it "sounds too simple"? Personally, I think we seriously overstate effectiveness of methods appealing to virtues, morality and "if only people would...". A lot of things in life are indirectly related to material wealth, you can improve pretty much anything by throwing more money at it. And we also know that things like "hard work" and "discipline" are overrated; people usually behave the way they do because of the environment they're in, and you can manufacture discipline by a mix of glucose and (in more extreme cases) some anti-ADHD medication.
I think we're as a society ignoring the obvious because it's easier to blame someone's lack of virtue than actually invest resources into solving their problems.
Yes, that argument nobody is making is indeed absurd.
Perhaps the reason wealthier children are healthier is because their parents have discipline and work hard to provide a safe, healthy, stimulating environment for their children, which includes retaining steady gainful employment and using the proceeds from that employment to provide food, shelter, and education for the children. This will not magically happen among poor children if you give the parents some baseline income.
Did you RTFA? The improvements happened after families started gaining an extra $4k from a new casino that was opened in the area.
So yes, it did magically happened after the parents got a baseline income increase.
So you argue that instead of actually using the results of research we should focus our welfare using understanding based upon 19th century moralizations.
My parents put together made less than $4,000 a year when I was born. Yet, today they are not poor and neither am I. Nobody gave them any free money, why wouldn't I be skeptical of these studies?
My parents were poor because they were born in a shitty country with a shitty economic system and there wasn't anything they could do except leave. That's bad luck.
If you're born healthy in the US you start with opportunity and have to actively fuck it up.
Ahh so $4000 had rather more purchasing power than in the US then. I wondered about a salary that low.
You are resistant to early, empirical results that poverty causes negative outcomes for children, and you will require stronger evidence to overcome this resistance.
Fair I suppose, but it says a lot about your politics. And I'll leave it there.
The key observation is that a study published in Nature "found a correlation between child brain structure and family income. Simply put, family income is correlated with children’s brain surface area, especially among poor children. More money, bigger-brained kids."
This is supported by the Cherokee study: when the families became a bit better off ($4,000 a year) the kids did better when they grew up.
So it's missing the point to argue about how grown-ups might (or might not) "waste" money and whether cash is better than other forms of welfare. The point is that bringing up children in poverty creates a worse outcome for society as a whole.
The fact is that $4,000 a year for 20 years is a very small amount compared with the cost of US police, courts, and prisons. If a poor kid grows up, gets a job and pays taxes, that's a massive win for society compared with the same kid growing up in the sort of deprivation that leads to a life of crime and jail.