Re:Show HN: CloudScrape – Cloud-based web scraping platform
by jumperjake on Saturday October 17, 2015 @12:37PM
(#10404965)
You're confusing redistribution with scraping. Scraping publicly-accessible content is legal. Redistributing it is not (at least not in the US).
Google scraps webpages as a core competency.
Re:Show HN: CloudScrape – Cloud-based web scraping platform
by chinathrow on Sunday October 18, 2015 @04:21AM
(#10407585)
Google also adheres to the robots.txt standard. Most of the scrapers I block don't.
Re:Show HN: CloudScrape – Cloud-based web scraping platform
by jumperjake on Sunday October 18, 2015 @12:01PM
(#10408569)
Not correct. Google will completely ignore the rules in robots.txt if it deems it acceptable. I think there's a link to this somewhere in this comment page.
Re:Show HN: CloudScrape – Cloud-based web scraping platform
by chinathrow on Sunday October 18, 2015 @02:41PM
(#10409212)
They do not index the content but might add the URL, correct. You can have a meta noindex present and they won't index even the URL.
Re:Show HN: CloudScrape – Cloud-based web scraping platform
by kuschku on Saturday October 17, 2015 @01:16PM
(#10405163)
Putting it online allows me to scrape it, but not to republish it.
I might just want to train a neural network on extracting data out of websites, and, for that usecase, wget -m every website I can find.
How I use the data you present to me, as long as I don’t republish it, is my decision. If you give me a license to read it, you also give me the license to copy it onto up to 7 different media at the same time, and to show it to up to 7 friends at the same time.
Since you're clearly not a content creator, and have decided since you didn't work on it it has no value, but putting something online does not make content public domain.