News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber taxi-hailing app does not break law, High Court rules by matthewmacleod on Friday October 16, 2015 @08:32AM (#10398816)
How is this a sensible remark? The app functions in exactly the same way as a taximeter, only the implementation is different.

You can read the judgement for more information, it's pretty detailed.

A device for recording time and distance is not a device for calculating a fare based on time and distance, let alone one based on more than that, including the fare structure itself, a necessary component to the calculation. The language of the statute is quite clear. The essence of a taximeter for the purpose of section 11 is that the device must be for the calculation of the fare then to be charged, based on whatever inputs are appropriate. Such a device is not simply recording and transmitting some or all of the inputs to a calculation made elsewhere, or receiving the output, that is the calculated fare. The Smartphone is not a “thing designed or adapted for a particular functional purpose” namely calculating fares for the PHV; see the Shorter OED. It is not a taximeter. The Smartphone with its Driver’s App may be essential to enabling the calculation to take place but that does not make it a device for calculating fares.

Re:Uber taxi-hailing app does not break law, High Court rules by wzdd on Friday October 16, 2015 @09:06AM (#10398970)
Your quoted text actually justifies Amelius' assertion: the functional category is the same, but the implementation differs, and the judgement (and the law) hinges on implementation.

All this means is that the definition of taximeter (as a single-purpose device) is now outdated. It's actually a pretty bad example of the law adjusting to new technologies.

Just because we like the outcome doesn't mean we have to like the way it happened.

Re:Uber taxi-hailing app does not break law, High Court rules by eterm on Friday October 16, 2015 @08:43AM (#10398868)
Doesn't this allow for any taximeter that farms the calculation to a server and gets the fare back?

In theory doesn't this open up a lot of competing taxi-meters which are effectively thin-client taximeters?