News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by kaonashi on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:41PM (#10396883)
You're assuming the economy is running at full capacity.
Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by tcbawo on Thursday October 15, 2015 @09:08PM (#10396958)
It would be interesting if basic income were tied to some combination of the Gini index and inflation rate. It would serve as a nice automatic offset to deflation, then fade away as the economy took off and wages increased.
Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by ItsDeathball on Thursday October 15, 2015 @09:41PM (#10397031)
What I'd like to see - and never see suggested in these discussions - is starting with a revenue-neutral carbon tax to fund a BIG. Since the tax would internalize the externalities of pollution and climate change, the government could cut subsidies and tax breaks for energy production and efficiency, and throw those savings into BIG as well. Anyone willing to be a below-average greenhouse gas emitter comes out on top, while anyone who owns a private jet is doing well enough not to care.
Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by cam_l on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:45AM (#10398512)
a revenue-neutral carbon tax to fund a welfare state..

Love the idea, but we had one of these for a couple of years, and at $23/t there was at least an order of magnitude less money in it than needed for a GBI. And per capita, we are among the highest carbon emitters on earth.

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by cmacpher on Friday October 16, 2015 @01:15AM (#10397583)
totally on board with something like this. I never understand why people say market forces will solve global warming, pollution and the future of energy.

Pollution is THE textbook case for an externality. By definition it cant be fixed by the free market.

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by dllthomas on Friday October 16, 2015 @10:18PM (#10403143)
Tying BI to observed inflation seems dangerous. Targeted inflation seems advisable. The former because a BI set higher than conditions can support seems likely to cause inflation, which would reduce (real) BI.
Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 15, 2015 @09:23PM (#10396995)
It's not so much an assumption, it's more just looking at our 5.5% unemployment rate (aka "the natural rate") and 3.5-4% NGDP growth.

Even if we aren't, this article provides no mechanism by which a BI would get us to full capacity or increase output at all. All it provides is a mechanism which would take us away from full capacity (If your boss is an unreasonable jerk, you can tell him to “take this job and shove it”...).

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by cam_l on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:56PM (#10397212)
I find it interesting that most people coming down against GBI do so under the assumption that coercion is the strongest incentive to work. I think it much more probable to look at GBI as separating the monopolistic part of the work market (if I don't work I will starve) from the competitive portion. Surely more competition in the employment market is a good thing?

Even then, I still think it is the third order effects of GBI (the ones we don't know about, or are to complex to model) that are most likely to cause massive societal upheaval. But then, maybe massive societal upheaval is what proponents of GBI are most excited about.

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 15, 2015 @11:46PM (#10397360)
...monopolistic part of the work market (if I don't work I will starve)...

That's not what "monopolistic" means. "Monopolistic" means one supplier.

Is the argument for BI really "we have no idea what will happen but it'll sure be massive and we believe without evidence that it will be good?"

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by cam_l on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:33AM (#10398480)
Missed the forest for the pedantries.

In an employment market, I am the supplier, my boss is the consumer. I hold a monopoly over my supply. All of my competitors offer my employer a slightly different product. The market is a monopolistic competitive market. On the other hand, my boss holds a temporary monopoly on my income, whether I eat or not.

With a GBI, these monopolistic parts of the market may be removed. My boss does not have to choose between me and another employee offering slightly different products, we can both be hired for the distinct bits of work we are can provide, and for an agreed price we value the work at, not an amount we need to satisfy our need to live. ie.it opens the employment market up to purer competition.

Is the argument for BI really...

Let me be clear, I don't think this is a good thing, but that is the sense I get from pro-GBI advocates. The scary thing is it most probably would be massive, in time, and there is little good evidence on the knock-on effects. I get why anti-GBI advocates are scared, they stand to lose money, but pro-GBI advocates should be scared too. So I guess what surprises me is they both should be arguing for trials, surely?

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by yummyfajitas on Friday October 16, 2015 @07:53AM (#10398675)
...my boss holds a temporary monopoly on my income, whether I eat or not.

The former is not the latter. Google "savings account".

Transaction costs are, economically, only a monopsony in the regime of small price changes compared to switching costs. I.e., if the cost of finding a new job is $2,000 then your boss can only underpay you by $2,000.

So I guess what surprises me is they both should be arguing for trials, surely?

I have no objection to trials. Unfortunately, a lot of BI "trials" are not really trials of BI at all - they are experiments in transferring wealth from outside the trial area into it. E.g., Mincome, the Uganda experiment. These trials certainly show that imperialism makes the empire richer.

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by kaonashi on Friday October 16, 2015 @03:08PM (#10401417)
Savings are stocks, incomes are flows.

http://www.boeckler.de/pdf/p_imk_wp_100_2012.pdf

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by cam_l on Friday October 16, 2015 @08:28AM (#10398799)
Google "savings account".

Google poverty.

Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by kaonashi on Friday October 16, 2015 @03:08PM (#10401414)
Re:A New Golden Age Part III: The Basic Income Guarantee by WalterSear on Thursday October 15, 2015 @09:29PM (#10397009)