News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by shanecleveland on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:16PM (#10394010)
Get internet service from cable provider with basic cable plus HBO for less than the advertised price of the internet service alone. Have to call back every year to get the promotional price back, which sucks. But we almost never watch the cable channels. Local channels in HD with a couple low-end antennas in the attic. And tend to watch HBO GO on a Roku, where we also have Netflix, Prime, etc.

Doing Sling during football season for ESPN.

As others have said, would like to have a better antenna setup with DVR that does not require subscription. Need a community-driven site where people can put in the type of antenna they have and what channels they get for more precise location-specific antenna recommendations.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by dexterdog on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:53PM (#10394274)
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by shanecleveland on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:09PM (#10394394)
Thanks. Seems to be pretty general, though. I just think it would be cool to combine this with anecdotal info from antenna users.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by aparks517 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:27PM (#10394976)
I've found http://tvfool.com to be very useful and precise. It appears to rely on physics rather than anecdotes, but you might find it worth a try.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by PretzelFisch on Thursday October 15, 2015 @03:04PM (#10395231)
tvfool.com has been the go to resource not only will it help you determin what type of antenna you will need but also what stations you can expect to recive as well as what direction the broadcasts come from so you can better am your antenna.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by narrowrail on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:47PM (#10394232)
>would like to have a better antenna setup with DVR that does not require subscription

I have been looking at a Channel Master[0] for this exact purpose; the cost is $250+HDD. It has an ethernet port which allows one to get an EPG [1] from Rovi, but it isn't required. If I pull the trigger maybe I'll do a write up and submit it.

[0]http://www.channelmaster.com/Antenna_DVR_s/336.htm

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_program_guide

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by Symbiote on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:12PM (#10394869)
Isn't an EPG part of the US-American standard? It has been part of the DVB (rest of the world…) standard since the beginning, so there's generally a button on a TV remote to display it.

(The DVB MPEG transport stream contains mostly video packets, but is interspersed with the EPG — in bits — and other media. Almost all TVs will cache the EPG, though earlier systems required the user to wait until the requested information was rebroadcast.)

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by JonathonW on Thursday October 15, 2015 @05:29PM (#10396125)
EPGs are part of the standard and broadcasters are required to transmit them, but there's no quality control on them beyond what the broadcaster does themselves; some broadcasters do a great job and some... don't.

That's where paid services like SchedulesDirect [1] come in; they pull data from the same source that Tivo and the cable/satellite companies are using, which (usually) gives you accurate scheduling.

[1] http://www.schedulesdirect.org/

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by shanecleveland on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:11PM (#10394410)
Thanks. A good option. Definitely would pay for itself over time if switch from a cable provider alternative. We've never had a DVR before, so hard to justify the jumping in cost.

It would be cool to see Roku or Apple TV combine this functionality.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by PaulHoule on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:25PM (#10394080)
With my OTA system I get a pretty good package of sports on the weekend and really enjoy the beautiful high definition imagery of golf, NFL and College Football, as well as the other sort of Futbol. You definitely get more with ESPN but you do not get better.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by shanecleveland on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:51PM (#10394258)
Agreed. I will always use our OTA signal rather than the cable package for overlapping channels. A handful of college games I want to be able to watch are on ESPN and Monday Night Football, as well. Plus nice to be able to turn on SportsCenter every now and then. A good lineup of other channels on Sling, too, which I just wanted to try out. Will likely quit Sling at the end of the year.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by noelsusman on Thursday October 15, 2015 @04:02PM (#10395591)
I heard Sling is laggy and unreliable. Have you had good experiences with it?
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by shanecleveland on Thursday October 15, 2015 @06:07PM (#10396324)
I'd say a good experience, but not great. The picture is good. I view primarily through a Roku connected to TV, but also nice to have access on a phone or tablet.

There can be a little lag time loading programing or jumping between shows. It has occasional reliability issues, cut-out midstream, didn't come back up from commercial break, but not the norm and may be device related.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by kxr on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:26PM (#10394086)
Interesting. What's your cable provider?
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by shanecleveland on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:39PM (#10394178)
Comcast. No complaints about internet service. I get 50mbps, which I believe is advertised at $80/mo. With the basic cable plus HBO promotional rate, our bill is about $72/mo.
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by soylentcola on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:58PM (#10394309)
I'll also chime in to say that we have a similar deal. Not as cheap but still less than a lot of people pay. I usually get 100-120mbps down and 10-ish mbps up, cable with a bunch of channels that I never watch (but my gf seems to want), some of the channels are in HD, many are just stretched SD, again, I don't really care since I don't watch much. The "main" channels are in HD at least. Also HBO (main channel in HD, others in scaled SD) but I only really use it for access to HBO Go.

As far as hardware, I only get the tuner/DVR from Comcast. Own my own modem and router. No phone service because it would be redundant.

Total cost is around $99/mo. I'd just as soon knock it down to internet only but that's around $70/mo and I'd spend the extra $30/mo subscribing to the various services that carry programming I currently access with our cable account login.

Not saying it's all sunshine and lollipops. We've had the usual billing and service tech issues that come with these sorts of companies that cut every corner imaginable. But when it works for most of the year, it does the job I guess.

On the subject of OTA antennas, I do have one hooked up to my PC's tuner card (since they did away with any unencrypted QAM over the cable lines....bastards) and when I watch one of the 5-10 channels I can pick up, the local HD broadcasts look so much nicer than the compressed stuff on cable. I actually prefer to throw a football game on my secondary monitor while I'm messing around on the computer rather than watch it over cable upstairs.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by equalarrow on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:00PM (#10394801)
We had something similar with Comcast in SF - 2 boxes and 1 dvr in the house, '50Mb' (I'll leave that in quotes) down, 10'ish-maybe up.

When we first moved into our place last year, the internet was stable and worked well enough (I say well enough because the d/l speed would fluctuate pretty consistently at night). Sometimes there was a hiccup, but overall, it worked.

Then this summer hit. No warning, no reasons, nothing - internet no longer stayed stable. It was all over the place. Some nights, 2mb down. So, you have to spend the time to talk to tech people since it's late at night and the kids are asleep and you just don't feel like getting on the phone to battle.

Got the usual excuses that service was being upgraded in the street, the line looked fine to them, it must be something on our end (that one's always predictable). Annnd of course, a tech came out, twiddled and fiddled and discovered our signal was low. Weird that it just happened now and now when the second cable run was installed when we moved in.

Because my wife and I (sadly) work from home after hours, when you have no internet, you're screwed. We weren't watching tv anymore and when we did it was netflix or game of thrones or silicon valley - all watchable via hbo go. So, I switched to Sonic.net (the best isp in the bay area in my mind) and haven't looked back.

Sure, we're running over at&t fiber (sigh) and capped at 50 down/5 up (sigh), but it just works. We're not running 50 one day, 80 another, 10 another and we're paying about the same for internet as we were on Comcast.

Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by canow on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:43PM (#10394200)
That sure ain't less the Internet service alone, I pay $25/month for 25mbit/s download
Re:The TV antenna is making a comeback by shanecleveland on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:08PM (#10394375)
It is for me in my location through Comcast at double the speed you are getting, which I want. I went and took a look. Comcast charges $60 for 25mbps and $75 for 50Mbps. Typically no promotions on just internet. Have to get phone or TV included for promotions. So I am paying less for more. Just have to be on top of it every year.