News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Drone Papers by gortok on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:39AM (#10393399)
There are lots of important points in this set of articles, but a few stand point:

- Congress has not defined what "assassination" means; and since they haven't defined it, the Executive Order 12333 is effectively meaningless. https://theintercept.com/drone-papers/the-assassination-comp...

- IMEIs are used to track targets. Can IMEIs be spoofed?

- Military Aged Males are considered enemy combatants. Effectively that means all males ages 18-49 are considered enemy combatants. Since you're guilty by association, your age makes you a target.

Re:The Drone Papers by rhino369 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:23PM (#10394060)
>Military Aged Males are considered enemy combatants. Effectively that means all males ages 18-49 are considered enemy combatants. Since you're guilty by association, your age makes you a target.

You are conflating what the US considers enemies before targeting and after a strike. The US doesn't just bomb any random male 18-49.

But when the US does target what it thinks is a legitimate target, it counts any unknown males killed in the strike as enemy. It doesn't use that assumption to do the strike. Only to count the enemy v. civilian kill total.

And it's a pretty reasonable assumption, depending on the circumstance. If the US drone strikes a Taliban hide out, the unknown males there were very likely foot-soldiers of the Taliban. If you accidentally blow up a wedding, then counting all the men is essentially lying.

But your sex and age don't make you a target. You being near a target doesn't really make you a target either. It makes you a tragic accident.

Unless the Taliban want to line up like 18th century foot soldiers, there are going to be people killed who aren't involved. Sending in ground troops would only make it worse.

And it's not like the Taliban aren't a real threat to Afghanistan. They just took over the 5th largest city in Afghanistan two weeks ago.

Re:The Drone Papers by gortok on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:39PM (#10394176)
> It makes you a tragic accident.

"We're not going to apologize for this, because you hung out with someone who was on our list, who we think was in this area, and so clearly you deserved being bombed by a drone. What? You borrowed your friend's phone? Oh well. Jackpot."

> And it's not like the Taliban aren't a real threat to Afghanistan. They just took over the 5th largest city in Afghanistan two weeks ago.

Why are we concerned with Afghanistan? There are literally dozens of other countries that are an actual threat to our National Interests (note: I did not say national security), so if we're going to go after countries, there are lots of other countries that should be ahead of a country half a world away.

One thing that sending in ground troops would do is hopefully reignite the debate as to whether we should be in that country at all.

A major problem with drones is that it allows us to make enemies without having to actually commit to a war. These Drone strikes are essentially a line-item on our defense department budget, and the CIA drone strikes are part of a black-budget we don't even know what it contains, let alone able to debate it.

If we're basing drone strikes on groups we're unfriendly with taking over countries, then we've got a lot of targets to go after.

The problem with not minding our own business and starting wars around the globe is that we continually get blowback, but we don't learn from it. It was "to keep the world safe for Democracy", then "safe from Nazis", then "Safe from communism", and now "safe from international terrorism", yet there is no debate in our congress about how our policies fuel any of these things.

When will there be a 'war' to keep the world safe from us?

Re:The Drone Papers by poof131 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:11PM (#10394405)
> One thing that sending in ground troops would do is hopefully reignite the debate as to whether we should be in that country at all.

Agree, but you're only part way. We really need to bring back the draft. On the ground in Iraq in 2008, watching ‘drone’ feeds of SF soldiers on missions on one screen and the stock market crashing on the other screen, all I could think about was “Don’t people care? There are soldiers risking their lives in foreign countries, doing things in America’s name, and all the TV talks about is houses and stock prices.” The number of contractors in country was probably 3 to 1 or more compared to military - Kenyans providing internal security, Filipinos working in the commissary, Pakistanis working in the chow hall, and Americans driving F-350s all over doing maintenance or whatever. The SF guys hated their contractor counterparts who took none of the risk they did and made a $1,000 a day just to provide a little training for the Iraqis. Being a pilot on a ground job, I hated the contract pilots making $20k a month for a job I easily could have done.

Until we’re all in it together, we won’t see change. As long as Americans can get upset, then turn off the TV and forget about it, nothing will happen, the military and civilian worlds will continue to drift apart. And a private, separate military is not good for this country.

Re:The Drone Papers by AngrySkillzz on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:46PM (#10394693)
Yup. No one cares until its their kid or the neighbor's kid getting shipped off to some far away warzone. While I disagree with the draft on moral terms, I think pragmatically it is the only way to properly align the incentives of the populace against wars that don't matter. Otherwise, the government can wage whatever wars they want and no one will be that bothered (as we've seen).
Re:The Drone Papers by meatysnapper on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:29PM (#10394988)
This cannot be stressed enough. A robotic military allows the government to wage wars with impunity because the average voter just doesn't care. If you have skin in the game, it would be different.

Perhaps a remedy for this would be to force the ranking members of congress to function as consuls, and make them live in Afghanistan for the duration of the conflict?

Re:The Drone Papers by anigbrowl on Thursday October 15, 2015 @05:50PM (#10396253)
That's true, but look how poorly we behave when we go in with troops instead, qua Iraq. The upsides (such as they are) of drone war are that it's very limited in scope and stimulates a conversation about objectives and interests, such as we are having now. As soon as you send troops in somewhere, a large swathe of the public stops even pretending to think about those issues and goes straight into 'support our troops, crush the enemy' mode, completely detached from any kind of strategic, fiscal, or ethical considerations.
Re:The Drone Papers by moskie on Thursday October 15, 2015 @03:18PM (#10395308)
My problem with this perspective is that you're suggesting we go out of our way to put more people (US soldiers) in danger.

If we (the US, or the military, or what have you) determine that a certain military act is justified, I think the approach should be to do it in a way to minimizes the danger as much as possible.

I can't imagine going to a soldier (who might be your son) and saying, "Hey, so, we could do this with a drone, but we'd prefer instead to put your life on the line."

Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @03:22PM (#10395338)
It's a form of checks and balances.

Right now we can see that the more we can outsource the wars, the less public cares about them. Which incidentally also means the other side has to figure out a more drastic way to make us stop. Drones are terrorist-breeding machines.

Re:The Drone Papers by korisnik on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:19PM (#10394473)
>it counts any unknown males killed in the strike as enemy. It doesn't use that assumption to do the strike.

Imagine for a moment that someone (be it some foreign agency, US police, army or whoever) did the same in America, to American citizens. Would you be outraged by your explanation?

"Hey, it's not like they're targetting them specifically. They're just deciding that they were all enemy combatants post-factum."

Re:The Drone Papers by anigbrowl on Thursday October 15, 2015 @05:44PM (#10396222)
I wouldn't be. That's the basic rationale of terrorists (both the foreign and domestic varieties). I don't think the Boston bombers were motivated by a specific hatred of athletics fans, or other demographic characteristics of their victims; they just knew it was a big static crowd with lots of media and weak security. The primary product of a terroristic enterprise is 'a scene of carnage' intended to communicate an experience of trauma to as wide an audience as possible.
Re:The Drone Papers by rhino369 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:39PM (#10395073)
If someone was bombing America, the way they were tallying the enemy combatants wouldn't really be a huge concern, to be honest.

Let's say the Michigan Militias sack Windsor, Canada. And Canada drops a bomb on their clubhouse. And a bunch of redneck young men are killed. You gotta assume they were part of the militia.

Re:The Drone Papers by ozten on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:07PM (#10396548)
> And a bunch of redneck young men are killed.

The lack of empathy around such a serious topic, is sad.

Re:The Drone Papers by ethbro on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:49PM (#10395143)
This analogy also relies on the assumption that the US was currently fighting a military insurgency or civil war.
Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:40PM (#10395077)
You should be, but for a different reason than if they were targeting those people specifically. Both are atrocities, but precision is very important in such discussions, otherwise we will turn into an angry mob.
Re:The Drone Papers by ctdonath on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:16PM (#10394453)
May want to review that stance in light of the fact that, like most countries, all male American citizens age 17-45 are legally part of the US Militia (and, until creation of the National Guard, were expected to be suitably armed & trained). When one country is at serious war with another, targets may not just be active combatants, but anyone officially positioned to become one. There are relevant & valid axioms, held to by warring parties, which do not differentiate between "combatants" and "non-combatants". In an existential crisis, fine distinctions are often discarded. Ugly memes, yes.
Re:The Drone Papers by Lawtonfogle on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:35PM (#10395034)
>You being near a target doesn't really make you a target either. It makes you a tragic accident.

You know, had you not worn that short skirt... well that tragic 'accident' wouldn't have happened.

Re:The Drone Papers by grandalf on Thursday October 15, 2015 @11:52AM (#10393849)
> Military Aged Males are considered enemy combatants. Effectively that means all males ages 18-49 are considered enemy combatants. Since you're guilty by association, your age makes you a target.

As an American citizen I'm so ashamed that we do this.

Re:The Drone Papers by whatafarce on Thursday October 15, 2015 @11:56AM (#10393878)
Shame? How about anger, or rage, or wrath? How about an inflexible demand to stop war crimes.

No one wants to conduct a meaningful opposition because the American system will destroy them. We are ruled by fear.

Re:The Drone Papers by grandalf on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:00PM (#10393898)
Well yes, all that too. I agree with your statement about lack of opposition/dissent. It is horrible.
Re:The Drone Papers by NN88 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @06:05PM (#10396315)
What would you do to stop the war crimes committed by these very targets?
Re:The Drone Papers by grandalf on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:00PM (#10396756)
could you explain what your question means? Who do you mean by targets?
Re:The Drone Papers by NN88 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:28PM (#10396836)
Why should I have a problem with taking out this guy? https://theintercept.com/drone-papers/the-life-and-death-of-...
Re:The Drone Papers by grandalf on Friday October 16, 2015 @12:16AM (#10397439)
Arguably you wouldn't object to taking out nearly any random person on the other side of the world who you didn't know personally. That's not the point.

It's a lot easier to just randomly assassinate people across the world than to come up with a sound policy that protects our interest while also obeying our values as a people. Historically, western culture has not condoned execution without trial.

The notion of just lumping anyone within an age range into the category of combatants is so antithetical to what the US ought to stand for, that it's really quite shameful. It's only a small degree away from the ethos of so-called terrorists, who just try to kill anyone they can.

What it boils down to is that the US is practicing terrorism abroad. I'm sure there would be circumstances where I'd approve of drastic measures, but at this point I'm very far from convinced that such tactics are remotely necessary or appropriate.

Re:The Drone Papers by PythonicAlpha on Thursday October 15, 2015 @04:54PM (#10395925)
> Military Aged Males are considered enemy combatants. Effectively that means all males ages 18-49 are considered enemy combatants. Since you're guilty by association, your age makes you a target.

A German newspaper wrote, that males with an age of 12 years up are considered legit targets.

Re:The Drone Papers by nkw on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:02PM (#10393911)
>- IMEIs are used to track targets. Can IMEIs be spoofed?

Yes. Relatively trivially.

Re:The Drone Papers by throwaway7767 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:47PM (#10394231)
Off-topic, but do you know any phones that can be easily hacked to change the IMEI? I know technically it's possible, and I know the hacks exist because I've seen shady sites offering the service, but I'd like to get a phone where I could rotate the IMEI myself when I change SIMs, so it would not be quite so easy to map the SIM to a person by watching for common IMEIs.

I guess the best bet would be something that runs OsmocomBB, but AFAIK that's not really a good choice for a day-to-day phone.

Re:The Drone Papers by BuildTheRobots on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:31PM (#10395004)
I was going to say the exact opposite; that it's in no way trivial and that possessing the tools and information to do so is illegal in a number of European countries.

More information would be greatly welcomed :)

Edit: On reflection that sounds extremely dodgy... I got curious a few months ago and couldn't turn up much, so I'd certainly classify it as more difficult than trivial... but then I am still curious.

Re:The Drone Papers by venomsnake on Thursday October 15, 2015 @03:34PM (#10395422)
First result on search

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vivek.imei...

Imei changing is trivial. But you are still on the same number.

Now - to change numbers on the fly requires telco assistance. And some very very interesting toys.

Re:The Drone Papers by runjake on Thursday October 15, 2015 @04:10PM (#10395656)
This only changes the apparent IMEI at the OS level to mask oneself from apps that pry.

The hardware is still using the same old IMEI as far as the phone company and SIGINT is concerned. This is not readily, or trivially, changeable.

Re:The Drone Papers by viraptor on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:58PM (#10396750)
I believe it was easier and possible in older phones. For example if you get an SL45 somewhere, I remember you had to flash your IMEI (or any IMEI) after the firmware change - otherwise it failed to register on the network. That would suggest it wasn't only as software level.
Re:The Drone Papers by BuildTheRobots on Friday October 16, 2015 @09:35AM (#10399113)
On those older phones the radio and phone application tended to be highly combined and running on the same processor, so re-writing the firmware would require you to reprogram hardware identifiers (there's a handful of embedded PCs at the moment where the ethernet MAC address isn't actually stored in NV memory so also has to be set on boot). -but yeah, you _need_ IMSI and IMEI as minimum to register on a network.

As far as I know, nearly every "modern" or smartphone has distinct separation between OS+applications and the radio world to the point where they're not only running separate firmware (anyone flashing android images will have seen this) but they're running on physically separate CPUs.

The other sad thing about the older phones (I've got a 6310 and a 7110 on my desk at the moment) is that they often don't support A5/3 encryption, so you can't actually use them on most modern networks (I believe it's the encryption; if anyone else knows better please tell me) -so if you're desperate to change the IMEI for some reason you can't just use an ancient handset to do it. It also means I can't throw off the shackles of this modern world and re-live 1990's hardware :(

I guess my original question could be better phrased as "does anyone know if it's possible on a _modern_ handset -and as it's device specific; which ones?"

I also feel I should point out a couple of "good" reasons for the macro operators not wanting people to have the ability. As it's the hardware identifier, it's used to blacklist stolen handsets -and anything that discourages kids from stealing my phone at knifepoint is probably a good thing. Different handsets also have all sorts of odd network quirks too. For macro operators, being able to profile how different handsets behave on their network can be extremely useful just for the sake of keeping the network running properly.

My sudden paranoid realisation though is that if you're a TLA, being able to go from IMEI to make/model of handset and therefore know exactly what exploits to use, must be quite useful o_0