News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Case for Getting Rid of Borders Completely by mahyarm on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:44AM (#10391716)
Strong borders came with the welfare state to avoid a tragedy of the commons.

Remove various fundamental benefits such as public school, medical care, welfare, transit, subsidized X and the millions of other benefits created in the past 120 years and open borders are not as big of a deal anymore. You just need to hop on a boat and arrive at ellis island, like the ancestors of many americans today.

There are also parallels with city zoning laws. Go buy a house and find out how many restrictions and regulations there are on the parcel of land that you have purchased. And also see how much resistance you will get from the local politically active populace if you dare try to change things. Such as creating density. NIMBYism almost seems like a instinctual human reflex.

In other places where there isn't a welfare state and so on, it's usually straight up racism and ethnic nationalism.

Re:The Case for Getting Rid of Borders Completely by calibraxis on Thursday October 15, 2015 @04:30AM (#10392008)
Where do I find evidence for this? I just checked, and the welfare state started in the 1880's by German conservatives, to fight bottom-up democracy and socialism. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_state#History_of_welfa...)

Far before then, rulers and nation states restricted human movement. (http://newint.org/features/1991/09/05/simply/)

Anyway, the welfare state (which includes government investment in fundamental tech which led to advances like computing, internet, etc) is a major driver of innovation and growth. More humans coming in, treated well, can obviously contribute. (As they already do, exploited for the most miserable societal tasks.)

Re:The Case for Getting Rid of Borders Completely by notahacker on Thursday October 15, 2015 @04:46AM (#10392052)
It's historically inaccurate, but in practice true that without slowing down immigration it's pretty much impossible to sustain a system in which people "looking for work" are entitled to higher PPP incomes and better services than labourers in virtually all the rest of the world. (But there are obvious drawbacks to taking things to the opposite extreme and banning all immigration: it might be a lot more difficult and expensive to run the NHS without immigrant healthcare professionals, for example)

But of course you're right that borders have been closed by leaders believing they help enforce cultural and political stability for eons before that.

Re:The Case for Getting Rid of Borders Completely by LoSboccacc on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:43AM (#10392753)
official welfare state might have become a thing just recently but the concept behind like redistribution of wealth and creating opportunities for class mobility predates it by a couple millenia

http://www.britannica.com/topic/alimenta http://www.britannica.com/topic/civitas

Re:The Case for Getting Rid of Borders Completely by arethuza on Thursday October 15, 2015 @04:58AM (#10392081)
"Strong borders came with the welfare state"

The Hadrian and Antonine walls close to where I am suggest otherwise. Also a lot of borders well before the "welfare state" were policed carefully to collect taxes - which is why smuggling was such a big thing in many areas.

Re:The Case for Getting Rid of Borders Completely by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:34PM (#10394143)
I agree that the GP's statement is disconnected from history, but I'm not sure that your counterexample works. Rome had "the dole" by the time of Julius Caesar (the "bread" in "bread and circuses").
Re:The Case for Getting Rid of Borders Completely by charlesism on Thursday October 15, 2015 @04:19AM (#10391976)
"Strong borders came with the welfare state"

I don't know what what you mean by "strong borders" but I can't think of any likely interpretation where I could agree with your statement. I'd say centralization of power, and the advancement of technology, have more relevance.