Re:Philosophy of Computer Science [pdf]
by mtdewcmu on Wednesday October 14, 2015 @10:03PM
(#10390889)
"such broad definitions can quickly degenerate into pancomputationalism: everything computes. And, if everything computes, computation is an uninteresting concept. The brain computes, but so does a piece of wood. Computation is simply another word for behaviour subject to (natural) laws. The Universe is a big computer, computing its own future — grand but somewhat vacuous."
- nice quote from the link you posted.
"A “computational theory of the mind” is along the same lines as having “a computational theory of the weather”, in which the earth is seen as a computer and the weather what it computes. It’s a metaphor that gives the illusion of understanding, without telling us whether tomorrow will rain or not — akin to using élan vital to “explain” life or scansoriality to “explain” propensity to climbing."
http://researchblogs.cs.bham.ac.uk/thelablunch/2015/07/what-...