News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by gnaritas on Thursday January 24, 2008 @07:19PM (#103862)
As the music industry is now learning... music is a service, not a product. Its short run as a product (records, tapes, CDs) was an artificial creation that still made some sense when bound to physical media (a product). No one really has a good solution yet, but it seems that information really doesn't like being a product.
Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by rms on Thursday January 24, 2008 @07:23PM (#103864)
One of these days, information is going to be free, I promise you.
Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by bayareaguy on Thursday January 24, 2008 @07:45PM (#103881)
If I ever get a pet, I'm going to name it 'information' just so you can keep your promise.
Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by rms on Thursday January 24, 2008 @08:02PM (#103890)
Well, for metaphor's sake, I hope Information can fend for himself in the wild.
Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by apotheon on Friday January 25, 2008 @07:25AM (#104070)
Is Metaphor the name of your pet?
Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by yters on Friday January 25, 2008 @02:10AM (#103993)
Information is inherently free, dissemination isn't.
Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by apotheon on Friday January 25, 2008 @07:27AM (#104071)
Upvoted, because what you said was strictly true and possibly insightful. (Is it still insightful whether the person who coined it actually had the insight that the statement implies?) I'm not really sure what you meant to imply, however, so I hesitated before upvoting.

Probably more information than you needed.

Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by yters on Friday January 25, 2008 @03:14PM (#104314)
Actually, I think it would have been more insightful for me to say interpretation isn't free. Dissemination matters, but the interpretation is primary.

Information is inherently free because information is basically numerical, and anyone can (potentially) think of any number. However, information is only useful when the numbers are correlated with actions or objects. It's this correlation that is truly valuable, and the creation of the correlation requires resources (i.e. time and energy).

Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by rms on Friday January 25, 2008 @02:13AM (#103994)
One of these days information dissemination is going to be free, I promise you.

That day is today, actually. http://thepiratebay.org/

Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by yters on Friday January 25, 2008 @03:05PM (#104302)
No, dissemination always consumes resources. I'm not just talking about the resources for sharing files, which are minimal. The real resources consumed are time and energy creating/discovering the information in the first place and putting it in a format that is usable. That's why people need some kind of guaranteed reimbursement for their discoveries and limited IP is a good idea.
Re:Bill Gates Calls for "Revision of Capitalism" by davidw on Thursday January 24, 2008 @07:28PM (#103870)
I'm a little bit more concerned with software myself. Bands (good ones, especially) can perform to make money. Programmers can't, really. Locking everything up on a server, and only handing out web pages is one answer, I guess...