News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There's No DRM in JPEG – Let's Keep It That Way by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @11:26PM (#10384840)
That's bullshit. Probably the first thing that would die would be the crappier part of the web - the one made to earn lots of money. Bye bye ad-sponsored clickbait image bullshit sites. Hello again honest communities. Sure, there would be lot of plagiarism, but it wouldn't stop people from creating content. Best content is often created by people who want to create something so that it exists, not just to make a buck out of it. Open source code is not an exception, it's the rule.
Re:There's No DRM in JPEG – Let's Keep It That Way by mahranch on Wednesday October 14, 2015 @05:45AM (#10385759)
> That's bullshit. Probably the first thing that would die would be the crappier part of the web - the one made to earn lots of money. Bye bye ad-sponsored clickbait image bullshit sites.

No, it wouldn't. Because if copyright vanished, I'd be one of the people trying to take advantage of it. It would be open season. A lot of my buddies would do the same.

I think you underestimate just how greedy people are.

Re:There's No DRM in JPEG – Let's Keep It That Way by throwawaykf05 on Wednesday October 14, 2015 @08:00AM (#10386084)
> Best content is often created by people who want to create something so that it exists, not just to make a buck out of it.

While true to some extent, if we want these people to keep making more of this "best content", we should also enable them to "make a buck out of it". Else they will (and do) go do something else to make a buck and we'll be worse off for it.

> Open source code is not an exception, it's the rule.

How often do people get paid for open source projects? How often do people get paid for writing custom, proprietary code? If your answers to these questions don't make obvious the fallacy of your statement above, all I can say is you're living in a bubble.

Re:There's No DRM in JPEG – Let's Keep It That Way by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 14, 2015 @09:36PM (#10390807)
> While true to some extent, if we want these people to keep making more of this "best content", we should also enable them to "make a buck out of it". Else they will (and do) go do something else to make a buck and we'll be worse off for it.

I agree, but there is a subtle difference in mindset here I think a lot of people miss - creating something to make money is a different thing from creating something and making money on it. Instrumental vs. terminal values. We want to have more people building things so that those things exist (i.e. making fun movies so that they're fun, or building tools to solve a problem), support them by e.g. making sure they aren't bothered by stuff like food and shelter - paying them. What we want to have less is people making things in order to make money off it, because their incentives are to create worst possible thing that still sells.

> How often do people get paid for open source projects? How often do people get paid for writing custom, proprietary code? If your answers to these questions don't make obvious the fallacy of your statement above, all I can say is you're living in a bubble.

Of course people are paid more for writing propertiary code, and I'm also aware of the trend to pay people for making open-source code which will be then monetized by e.g. charging for support. But this is irrelevant to the topic. Even most of the tools you use for your daily work as a programmer would still exist if suddenly no one got paid for code anymore.

My point is - code and art is something better if done by someone who cares primarily about them than by someone who cares primarily about the paycheck for them.