From what I understand, the actual proposed replacement for the corporate income tax is much simpler: eliminate it and replace it with a much more comprehensive capital gains tax. Then require companies to be much more forward with paying dividends.
The problem is that corporations use the infrastructure and resources of countries they operate in. So you would still have a situation of a multinational company using the resources of country X without necessarily paying any tax for using the resources of country X.
This is not sustainable.
For human resources: income tax on salaries, unemployment insurance, medical insurance etc.
For some materials: excise tax.
For real estate: property tax.
Uh, what exactly is the difference between consuming and investing in assets? Most investment in assets is actually just a claim to consume some of the ROE.
Also, it's not clear to me how shifting cash flows into something makes an asset (or how a physical asset could directly benefit from increased cash flow [not sure how this is even possible; I can't pump FRN's into my car's gas tank]).
Why are you fixating on share price? Now how are you going to tax LLC, LLP, etc.? Privately traded corps that don't have a market price?
As for privately traded corps and partnerships: My proposal was to tax capital gains. This could be done at each realization event, and at that point your transaction will usually have a market price. If you are exchanging stock in two privately traded corps, some way to determine fair market value will have to be found, but that seems to be an edge case to me.
Most limited liability organizations also don't have equity, which creates another loophole in your system. Now you're starting to get into why corporate income tax is complex.
Sure those shareholders will pay cap gain or personal income, but now since you eliminated corporate tax completely, the net tax revenue of the country wal-mart operates in is no diminished.
This is a great idea to increase the wealth gap between developed countries and the rest of the world, for good or bad. Considering how many international conglomerates are American, European or Japanese.
Developing countries wouldn't stand a chance this way.
Note that those are the pre-2008 hedge fund fees and the fees are presently less than that.
Everybody who has something to lose will vote against a simpler system, doesn't matter whether its a private company or government.
There are lots of economic arguments for very simple tax systems that prioritise revenue collection over other things. But a lot of people would see them as "unfair" and therefore unjust.
cruft + tax payers writing law + tax collectors writing law
And a direct property tax is also not a good idea, as then you tax people for having property, not for using their property.
A low corporation tax is valuable because it attracts foreign businesses, but that is necessarily zero-sum.
As far as I can tell, money will exit corporations in three ways: 1) salary, 2) shares and 3) payments for goods/services, mostly to other corporations. Income and capital gains taxes will take care of 1 and 2. The company won't owe taxes, but whichever natural person receives the money will. As for 3, my proposed system would be captive: because it doesn't charge corporate taxes, corporations won't have any motivation to try and move their earnings to other corporations (as they couldn't be taxed any lower).
You want companies to spend, to increase economic cash flow and generate jobs, which is why existing corporate taxes are on net income, not revenue or costs.
Corporate income tax today allows for companies to pay employees and buy goods/services without increased tax cost. It incentivizes cash flow into the economy and job generation by taxing whatever is left over (net income) after doing business.
Sure those shareholders will pay cap gain or personal income, but now since you eliminated corporate tax completely, the net tax revenue of the country wal-mart operates in is no diminished.
This is a great idea to increase the wealth gap between U.S. and the rest of the world, for good or bad. Considering how many international conglomerates are U.S. based.
Why don't we cut down everything to a couple of manageable groups that can be tightened down? I think the following set of taxes should capture mostly everything:
- Personal income including gifts, inheritances, capital gains, all on a set of progressive scales. This should include work benefits (like company cars) and probably include loans taken out.
- Use of public resources (property tax, vehicle registration tax, RF use...), taxed based on the specific usage (e.g. vehicle weight, or even kilometers driven).
- A consumption tax (VAT) could be added, although this doesn't seem necessary to me.
Thinking about this for a couple of minutes, I don't see any obvious problems. Applicability of the personal income tax would be a crucial point, and care would need to be taken to avoid loopholes. Why aren't tax systems as simple as that?