News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics by coldtea on Monday October 12, 2015 @08:36AM (#10374080)
>You're completely missing the fact that I'm not talking about ethics here.

I can't see how this can be, since the core of what we are discussing is a supposed "Copenhagen interpretation of ETHICS".

>I'm talking about ethical positions, a meta-level up; and I'm saying that you subscribe to CIE while calling CIE a straw man.

Again, no logical contradiction there.

As I explained I subscribe to CIE+ (a superset).

This means that I can both subscribe to CIE (as it's contained in the superset CIE+) AND find it when discussed alone (without the extra additions) lacking/a strawman.

For a crude example of that, one can logically subscribe to S+ ("men are rapists sometimes") and still view S ("men are rapists") as a strawman.

Re:The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics by philh on Monday October 12, 2015 @09:41AM (#10374380)
Talking about ethics: this is good and this is bad

Talking about ethical positions: some people say this is good and this is bad; other people say...

I still think that what you call a strawman is just something you actually believe, and that you're interpreting it as a much stronger claim than it actually is. But I don't care enough to argue further.