News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by dogma1138 on Sunday October 11, 2015 @10:54AM (#10369469)
There were active resistances in most occupied countries including France. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Resistance

However a big difference between occupied populations and Jews is that Germany for the most part left the occupied population alone. Yes they were still oppressed and in many cases fell into poverty however they weren't hunted down by the SS, gathered and then shipped to concentration camps, ghettos, and later to extermination camps.

As far as Ghettos go then for the most part it was a "Polish" issue, there weren't many Ghettos outside of Poland, while it appears now that the German population knew much more about the treatment of Jews than what previously thought or admitted the German's kept Germany clean, and only had labor and work camps within Germany and for the most part France and other occupied countries which sadly provided much better conditions for the most part which enabled the Germans to dismiss the claims of what was happening in Poland and in the eastern front as Jewish and later Allied propaganda.

And this is a major issue, while French, Polish, Danish, Dutch and other nationalities had resistances they for the most part were fighting for ideals and their personal freedom. A population in risk of genocide has to literally fight for it's life. If Jews the capabilities of supporting a continuous armed resistance the Holocaust could've been avoided (this isn't claiming that the end result would've resulted in less deaths) because it would be much less likely that the Germans could've as easily transported as many Jews at that much of an ease during the final solution.

The final solution was so unthinkable that even the Jews didn't believe it until the news broke out in the final year of the war in Europe, the majority of the Jews were transported from ghettos and work camps and thought that they are just are being put into a new camp, the level of deception that was put into the final solution was truly unbelievable including letting the "red-cross" (still no clear if this was a show or the actual red-cross) visit the Jews in the big Ghettos before transferring them to the death camps to further pacify and calm down the population.

So yes arming at risk populations might make a huge difference in the end even if you only consider that difference to be the way they died rather than the pure numbers, but in modern times it's also an issue. Tribal genocide (which sadly being going since even before colonial times) cannot be just as easily compared to the Holocaust, if you are the population too much you might still get a Genocide in which the original at risk population isn't the victim but now the perpetrator so you end up with constantly fueling an ever shifting conflict.

Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by dalke on Sunday October 11, 2015 @05:51PM (#10371233)
If what you say is true, then that weakens the authors thesis pretty drastically.

For example, you say: "even the Jews didn't believe it until the news broke out in the final year of the war in Europe". This uprising took place almost two years before V-E day, which means the Jews in Warsaw were not aware that they were "literally" fighting for their lives. They were instead fighting for their human rights, and their way of life. (We know they were destined for extermination camps, but they didn't; if what you say is correct.)

The author also points out that the deportations were 'ostensibly for resettlement in labor camps, but almost always for extermination' and 'Often, the Judenrat was told that as long as the ghetto worked hard to produce factory goods for the Germans, the ghetto would be allowed to survive.' Thus, how did the Jews of Warsaw know that genocide was planned for them, and not, say, work camps?

If they did not know, then thesis - that weak gun laws can help prevent genocide - is actually a broader one; that weak gun laws can help prevent ghettoization, or that weak gun laws can help prevent mass deportations.

Hence if there is any lesson to be learned, it sounds like the author is arguing for the increased weaponization of the Palestinians, in order to better reach the long agreed upon two state solution.

Another issue is that you added your own qualifier; "Tribal genocide ... cannot be just as easily compared to the Holocaust."

This is a different definition of genocide than the author. Or rather, when the "International Society for the Prevention of Crime", concluded "defensive measures are the most effective means for the prevention of genocide"; did that mean genocide as defined by the Genocide Convention? I think so. While you want to exclude "tribal genocide" from that definition.

In science there is an analysis error called "p-hacking". More specifically, if the correlation across the entire data set is too weak, some people will look at a subset which has a more detectable correlation. (XKCD calls this 'Hey, look at this interesting subgroup analysis'.) The problem is, the method of subsetting should be part of the significance analysis, and by excluding it, the p-value is artificially raised.

By choosing a subset of 'genocide', you weaken the intent of the essay. You say they cannot easily be applied to tribal genocide, which opens up the possibility that the can't be used for other genocides, and especially opens up the possibility that it can't be used in the US political context.

Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by EGreg on Sunday October 11, 2015 @12:05PM (#10369787)
The Polish had guns AND fought back. How did it help them? Hitler and Stalin both invaded anyway.
Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by dogma1138 on Sunday October 11, 2015 @12:42PM (#10369944)
Yes they did, but again it's not the same situation exactly there were plenty of Jews that escaped the concentration camps, and later the death camps in Poland and joined the resistance but the majority of them couldn't.

I made it quite clear that arming a population might not have a clear impact on the amount of deaths, but it will have a clear impact on the way they died.

The Polish people didn't "had" to fight, at least not for survival this isn't an attempt to make their fight any less heroic or meaningful but they fought for freedom and ideals rather than not being branded as cattle and led to their deaths.

If more Jews could revolt the final solution might not have happened, not in the way it did anyhow, the Germans could only execute it because they have had very little internal and external resistance in doing so. If there was a much bigger Jewish resistance and there would be revolts in every work camp, ghetto and concentration camp the Germans could possible have had to give up on their plans, the cold and calculated truth of the Holocaust is that the Germans found them selves with too many Jews on their hands where exploiting them began to cost more than what they got in return.

Heck they had to ask the Catholic church to annul the marriages between "pure" Germans and German Jews in mass because that presented them with a real problem of having to disclose and produce death certificates for dead German Jews to their former husbands and wives so they could remarry.

So yes a strong and armed Jewish resistance might have played a big role in the outcome of the Holocaust they didn't had to drive an invading army out, they didn't fight for the freedom of a country or the ideals of the nation they fought for their own survival and making the final solution too costly to execute as well as directly sabotaging it (which is something that the allied forces refuse to do in the form of not bombing train lines and even the incinerators of the death camps) could've resulted in a very different outcome.

And Poland eventually won it's freedom, they did inflict heavy losses on German troops, and eventually they did convince the USSR to leave as well, but as i said it's a completely different conflict.

Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by dalke on Sunday October 11, 2015 @06:31PM (#10371382)
> If more Jews could revolt the final solution might not have happened, not in the way it did anyhow,

Your conclusion is a bit tautological - if things were different then they wouldn't have happened the same way.

> the Germans could only execute it because they have had very little internal and external resistance in doing so.

Jews were not the only ones being killed. Everything you say should apply to Ukraine. Quoting Wikipedia:

> The Holocaust in Ukraine took place during the occupation of Ukraine by Nazi Germany.[1] Between 1941 and 1945, approximately 3,000,000 Ukrainian and other non-Jewish victims were killed as part of Nazi extermination policies, along with between 850,000 - 900,000 Jews who lived in the territory of modern Ukraine.[2][3] Original plans of genocide called for the extermination of 65% of the nation's 23.2 million Ukrainians,[4][5] with the remainder of inhabitants to be treated as slaves.[6] Over 2,300,000 Ukrainians were deported to Germany for slave labor.[7] In ten years' time, the plan effectively called for the extermination, expulsion, Germanization or enslavement of most or all Ukrainians. ...

> One of Hitler's ambitions at the start of the war was to exterminate, expel, or enslave most or all Slavs from their native lands so as to make living space for German settlers. ... Total civilian losses during the war and German occupation in Ukraine are estimated at four million, including up to a million Jews who were murdered by the Einsatzgruppen and local Nazi collaborators.

> If there was a much bigger Jewish resistance and there would be revolts in every work camp, ghetto and concentration camp the Germans could possible have had to give up on their plans,

Given that millions of non-Jewish Slavs were also massacred, how much more Jewish resistance would have been needed?

And like I said, if that thesis were true, then it would seem that the best way to achieve the two state solution for Palestine is to ship a huge amount of arms to the Palestinians. If not, what is missing in the comparison?

Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by dalke on Sunday October 11, 2015 @08:46PM (#10371881)
(My apologies about messing up the quotes. The paragraph stating "> If there was a ..." is from you. The previous two paragraphs are from Wikipedia.)
Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by EGreg on Sunday October 11, 2015 @12:46PM (#10369962)
I brought up the Polish because many of them did have to fight for survival, and many died.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties_of_Pol...

Approximately six million Polish citizens perished during World War II: about one fifth of the pre-war population. Most were civilian victims of the war crimes and crimes against humanity during the occupation by Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union.

Half of those were Jews. The other half were other Poles.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katyn_massacre

"The Polish people didn't "had" to fight, at least not for survival"

Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by dogma1138 on Sunday October 11, 2015 @01:04PM (#10370039)
Out of the 6M Polish casualties 3M of them were Jewish, the Polish people suffered extensively during WW2 there's no doubt about it.

Both the Germans and the Russians often practices universal punishment and exterminated entire villages for hosting resistance fighters and later on for cooperating with either Russian or German forces.

The 6M death figure which is horrible is also the total death accounts during the war which included Pols that died while serving in the Polish army, Poles that were conscripted to the German army, Poles who were Conscripted to the Soviet Army, Civilians who died in massacres, starvation, and disease.

Poland isn't the only country in which the civilian population encountered such acts, Germany wiped entire villages in Greece for showing the slightest sign of resistance and then wiped the nearest 3 villages as a warning to others.

War crimes always happens, but not every war crime is a Genocide, Poland might actually be a unique case because of how it was split between Stalin and Hitler and because of the animosity the Germans had towards it for "stealing" large parts of the "fatherland" after WW1.

But again it's hard to equate the crimes committed in Poland to Genocide, especially considering that even during the War both the occupied Polish government and the exiled Government continued counting loses of "ethnic" poles, which at the end amounted to about 10% of the pre-war "ethnic" poles population.

But that could've as easily been changed if the war would've dragged longer and once the Germans finished dealing with their "Jewish Problem" they would no longer see the Slavic people as "necessary slave labor".

Wars are shit, WW2 and the Holocaust is probably the shittiest of them all, but if you ask the Poles would they rather be armed and fighting or be the next inline for complementary train tickets you would probably get only a single response and that is we rather fight, there are many ways to die and while we all like idolizing heroic deaths there is almost no one that would rather not fight and die than die in naked in a gas chamber.

Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by DominikD on Sunday October 11, 2015 @01:43PM (#10370184)
> Out of the 6M Polish casualties 3M of them were Jewish

These numbers don't really add up and it's the upper bound Polish historians quote. The problem is that there were roughly 3M Jews in Poland before the war and census before and after the war showed ~3,5M population drop in total. So not only 6M seems excessive but 3M seems unlikely given that this would mean that roughly every single Jew died in the result of WWII. 3M/6M figures are never verified, PRL figures.

> but if you ask the Poles would they rather be armed and fighting or be the next inline for complementary train tickets you would probably get only a single response and that is we rather fight

Sure, most of us would rather fight. But this piece isn't about our will or ability to fight. I actually find it offensive that some random dude from across the ocean is using pieces of my history to justify his own agenda. One that has absolutely NOTHING to do with fighting against oppression, aggression or genocide but EVERYTHING to do with interests of gun manufacturers. I find this kind of articles dangerous in how cynical they are in exploiting fears we all have, that a group I'm a part of could be targeted, to push particular agenda. It's disgusting.

Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by dogma1138 on Sunday October 11, 2015 @01:56PM (#10370224)
Only 50,000 or so Polish Jews survived the Holocaust, the Germans have kept quite meticulous records and about 3.3M Polish Jews were killed during WW2.
Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by DominikD on Sunday October 11, 2015 @05:04PM (#10371029)
If I were responsible for counting in such circumstances as they were, I'd bump up the figures to make myself look good. For the same reason communist gov in Poland diminished casualties caused by Soviet actions. Self reporting is rarely accurate.
Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by dogma1138 on Sunday October 11, 2015 @06:33PM (#10371394)
It's based on pretty solid evidence from multiple sources (German, Russian, Polish records, Jewish congress records and interviews with both survives and camp workers) this is now entering David Icke's territory so have a good day.
Re:The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: Armed Jews vs. Nazis by merpnderp on Sunday October 11, 2015 @02:58PM (#10370457)
It's not just about winning. It's about making it as costly as possible for the other side to win. The Warsaw Uprising was a horribly costly victory for the Germans. And in the case of the Polish Jews there was no downside to fighting back.

And it's certainly not out of the question that a better armed Jewish resistance could have organized transport for a lot of Jews out of Nazi hands.