News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by striking on Saturday October 10, 2015 @02:26PM (#10366408)
It was inevitable that this would happen. I remember when Opera first added pop-up blocking and plenty of people got mad. This is the same thing: ads are burning energy, bandwidth, and our time.

Now that consumers have been subjected to piles of abusive ads, they're just blocking all of the ads regardless of how bad they are.

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by wutbrodo on Saturday October 10, 2015 @05:12PM (#10367028)
> Now that consumers have been subjected to piles of abusive ads, they're just blocking all of the ads regardless of how bad they are.

Not really; they're blocking all ads except the ones that are unblockable: ads masquerading as content (sponsored posts, etc). It's inevitable to a degree; most people are willing to whine loudly and pretend they have the moral high ground about things that are immediately visible, but unable to think more than one step ahead about the consequences of their actions.

Paid content is, by and large, a miserable failure[1] (just look at the history of paid apps relative to ad-supported and IAP), and ad-blocking is on the rise as well. This is just pushing publishers to break one of the oldest rules (and for good reason), and break down the wall between ads and content.

[1] With minor exceptions like publications that have established a very strong brand with people of relatively high net worth. It's not a coincidence that the only publications I read regularly that moved to paywalls happen to be over a hundred years old (NYT, WSJ, Economist)

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by striking on Saturday October 10, 2015 @05:17PM (#10367048)
Paid content is not always awful. Take this tasteful, sponsored Ashens video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WUGcjkdIfTk

There is a clear disclosure (no misleading marketing!) and he presents a new and interesting version of his usual show while incorporating the product.

It's not selling out, and it's fairly enjoyable (as evidenced by the rating counter on the video, as well as the comments).

If I must be advertised to, I prefer this method. Having watched the video, I would actually like to purchase the device mentioned. Not because it was shoved down my throat, but because it is relevant to me and I find it interesting.

The video merely brought it to my attention.

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by wutbrodo on Sunday October 11, 2015 @05:42PM (#10371204)
Sure, but as usual, anecdotal evidence isn't worth much[1]. I'm sure I can point you to traditional display ads that I've seen on the Web that are tasteful, useful, and unobtrusive. Does that obviate all the complaints people have about display ads overall? Of course not. Similarly, the amount of times I've heard a podcast say "this episode sponsored by blahblah, [explanation of blahblah]" doesn't erase the amount of examples I've seen of an article with a tiny "sponsored by X" at the top. And as is inevitable when financial pressure is great enough, you end up with even well-respected publishers resorting to stuff like this: http://adage.com/article/media/york-times-shrinks-labeling-n...

[1] I'm aware that you're explicitly providing a counter-example, so I'm not disagreeing with your comment. Just saying that it doesn't really address my point.

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by wutbrodo on Sunday October 11, 2015 @10:30PM (#10372202)
BTW I realize that my terminology was really confusing. By "paid content", I meant "content that you pay for". You appear to have responded to the part of my post about sponsored content. Just want to make sure that you weren't also reading the part of my comment about paid content and thinking of sponsored content.
Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by wpietri on Saturday October 10, 2015 @06:43PM (#10367283)
Paid content on the web has been bad because there has been a glut of free content.

But if we look at the history of print, paid content did quite well for a very long time. Books, you might recall, were pretty popular. Many magazines and newspapers used to make a great deal of their revenues from subscription fees.

Video similarly seems to have worked well when paid: movies have always been profitable. The recent "golden age of television" has been attributed to the increasing volume of paid content; the ad-supported stuff is seen as lower quality.

I use an ad blocker because I'm not interested in participating in a system that is based around manipulation of people. I pay for some media both old (e.g., Economist, NYT) and new (e.g., via Patreon). The system of ad-supported print content is certainly in trouble, and if I can help along its demise by using an ad blocker, I'm glad to do it. It'll be exciting to see what comes next.

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by wutbrodo on Sunday October 11, 2015 @06:26PM (#10371358)
> The recent "golden age of television" has been attributed to the increasing volume of paid content

Interesting, really? Do you have a source referring to this? The only theory I've heard is that as Hollywood studios have become financially more conservative (cf the dominance of remakes, reboots, sequels, prequels, etc relative to decades past), talent interested in taking risks has fled to television.

> Paid content on the web has been bad because there has been a glut of free content.

Right, and the glut of free content is facilitated by the incredibly low marginal cost of distribution. Buzzfeed has built their entire business on this: instead of "writers", they have "people with a spare ten minutes to Google a set of gifs"[1]. I don't see how this is a feature of the Internet that is going to disappear, especially since people have spoken loudly and clearly that, en masse, paid media will be ignored in favor of nominally free alternatives. Your book example is particularly useful in proving my point: those books that aren't encumbered by the monopoly power of copyright are freely available on Kindle or through Project Gutenberg. TL;DR: As long as there's a free alternative, people writ large won't pay, and as long

> I use an ad blocker because I'm not interested in participating in a system that is based around manipulation of people.

This is what bothers me about people who try to take the moral high ground about ad-blocking. How in God's name do you come to the conclusion that "not participating in a system" is anything but "not visiting those sites"? If you think Beats headphones are priced more for brand than quality[2], do you go "I refuse to participate in a system that overprices products based on fooling customers" and then merrily shoplift your way through their inventory?

[1] Side note: I love this site. http://buzzfeedminusgifs.tumblr.com/

[2] Note that I'm very uninterested whether people think Beats are fairly priced or not and don't have an opinion about it myself; I'm not an audiophile and was just parroting something I've heard a bunch of times for the purposes of constructing a hypothetical. Please don't respond to this comment arguing about Beats...

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by wpietri on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @09:26AM (#10380259)
I can't find where I read the notion on paid content originally, but it makes sense to me. With 3 network channels and the goal of maximizing ad revenue, you need a lot of stuff that a lot of people will watch, which mean generally adequate, inoffensive, middlebrow programming. Places like HBO and Netflix, though, live and die based on whether people a) sign up to pay, and b) keep paying. That gives a strong incentive to create very compelling, high-quality shows that a narrower audience will definitely watch. (I think the invention of reality TV has also helped, in that it has drained off the fraction of the audience that is happy with low-end, cheap-to-produce programming.)

Regarding me using an ad-blocker: your use of physical theft as an analogy for viewing content is just embarrassing on Hacker News. You should know better.

The difference is that if I steal headphones, the store is deprived of the headphones. Whereas if I read an article without also paying to download and display their ads, they still have the article. If they would like to only show content and ads at the same time, there are technological fixes they could apply. If they do, I won't be working around them.

They presumably haven't because there is value to them in people reading and sharing their content whether or not ads are viewed. And also because the marginal cost of a view is so small that it's best expressed in scientific notation. Personally, I don't bother trying not to read their stuff because a) I am looking for opportunities to pay people who are willing (e.g., I pay the NYT), b) I hope it'll contribute to the signal to them that their ad-driven model is not sustainable, and c) I'm not the level of obsessive that is going to carefully decide which sites to visit because I might be costing large media companies epsilon cents until they get their acts together.

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by cookiecaper on Saturday October 10, 2015 @05:01PM (#10366987)
The downside is that ads are going increasingly incognito, precisely to avoid things that explicitly filter them out. The basic act of renting an audience is not going to be stopped.
Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by striking on Saturday October 10, 2015 @05:05PM (#10367005)
Thank goodness there are rules against truly indistinguishable, native ads.

Because they mislead customers into thinking positive-leaning advertisements are actual reviews of products.

Further reading:

http://adexchanger.com/publishers/ftc-publishers-will-be-hel...

https://m.reddit.com/r/KotakuInAction/comments/38gocf/ethics...

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by cookiecaper on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:04PM (#10402306)
That's interesting because PR companies' entire job is to place "native ads".
Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by mtw on Saturday October 10, 2015 @04:50PM (#10366951)
Did you ever give consent for ads in your print newspaper? They "load" on the page, without asking
Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by jalfresi on Saturday October 10, 2015 @04:58PM (#10366979)
But they don't cost me actual real money both in terms of bandwidth costs and psychological cost (tracking induces paranoia which curbs my thought, which adjusts my online search behaviour, for one example). Printed adverts in a newspaper do not have these costs.
Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by mtw on Monday October 12, 2015 @11:27AM (#10375104)
They do cost real money. The price of the newspaper is proportional to the number of pages printed, including ad pages.

You are right about online tracking though.

Re:Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about ... by ForkFed on Saturday October 10, 2015 @04:01PM (#10366780)
This notion of "publishers" vs. "comsumers" is myopic ... we're all sitting in the same boat. Lot of benevolent and ad displaying publishers out there (f.x. stackoverflow) and same goes for lot of consumers who donate to content creators they cherish.