Re:What's your take on the save mysql?
by gojomo on Thursday January 07, 2010 @12:46AM
(#1036579)
I'm concerned about having a leading (by usership) free SQL database under the control of the leading (by revenue) proprietary SQL database vendor.
And, I believe it would ultimately be better for MySQL users for it to be under a more permissive, non-copyleft license. It allows for a broader commercial ecosystem.
But, I'm uncomfortable with regulators telling companies what to do with their lawfully acquired property/rights based on speculation about potential abuses that haven't even occurred yet.
And, I'm uncomfortable with someone who chose for their own benefit one doctrinaire set of rules -- the GPL -- now asking for the rules to be rewritten, against the wishes of the people to whom he sold his package of rights.
So I can't support the campaign, even though I'd like one of its sought end states (non-copyleft MySQL).
Maybe if someone other then Widenius led a purely-antitrust-based case for divesting or relicensing MySQL. As an advocate, he's tainted.
And, I believe it would ultimately be better for MySQL users for it to be under a more permissive, non-copyleft license. It allows for a broader commercial ecosystem.
But, I'm uncomfortable with regulators telling companies what to do with their lawfully acquired property/rights based on speculation about potential abuses that haven't even occurred yet.
And, I'm uncomfortable with someone who chose for their own benefit one doctrinaire set of rules -- the GPL -- now asking for the rules to be rewritten, against the wishes of the people to whom he sold his package of rights.
So I can't support the campaign, even though I'd like one of its sought end states (non-copyleft MySQL).
Maybe if someone other then Widenius led a purely-antitrust-based case for divesting or relicensing MySQL. As an advocate, he's tainted.