One dish that I have directly compared sous-vide against more traditional techniques is pork shoulder. My "traditional" technique is oven-cooking, a process that takes 6 hours at 325 F. In sous-vide, the shoulder takes longer, more like 24-72 hours, but the temperature is lower, 135 F (http://sousvidely.com/sous-vide-pulled-pork/). Also, it's in a bag. The sous-vide version is better in many ways -- it's got more juice and color and tastes fresher -- and it's way easier because I don't have to turn and baste it every 2 hours.
But yeah, I don't love the consumables of sous-vide. I reuse bags and water whenever I can.
One dish that I have directly compared sous-vide against more traditional techniques is pork shoulder. My "traditional" technique is oven-cooking, a process that takes 6 hours at 325 F. In sous-vide, the shoulder takes longer, more like 24-72 hours, but the temperature is lower, 135 F (http://sousvidely.com/sous-vide-pulled-pork/). Also, it's in a bag. The sous-vide version is better in many ways -- it's got more juice and color and tastes fresher -- and it's way easier because I don't have to turn and baste it every 2 hours.
But yeah, I don't love the consumables of sous-vide. I reuse bags and water whenever I can.