News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by madez on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:22AM (#10359136)
Your arguments are irrelevant nowadays.

If my filesystem gets corrupted, I boot into a live cd, just like everybody does.

With btrfs and integrated parity, checksums, cow and scrubbing on the horizon filesystem reliability is only a minor thing to care about. With subvolumes we can snapshot as many things atomically as we want.

Simlicity is now what trumps your arguments overwhelmingly. The filesystem hierarchy has to be intuitive, consistent and simple, which it is currently not.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by thaumaturgy on Friday October 09, 2015 @06:55AM (#10359227)
There was a major ext4 bug just earlier this year that caused data loss for some folks: https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=785672

Booting a LiveCD would not have fixed affected partitions.

You're not the first on HN to say in so many words that the sometimes expensive lessons I've learned over 30 years of computing are suddenly irrelevant now. I used to argue that, but I don't see much point to it anymore.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by madez on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:15AM (#10359293)
One of your arguments was to put /bin and /sbin onto a seperate partition so that if something happens, it’s unlikely that /bin and /sbin are affected. In reality however, nobody cares about /bin and /sbin at all.

Another argument was more fine grained permission control. You can do that by other means, for example with subvolumes.

So, after all, possible corruptions are not alleviated by complex partition struture, or only with a bad trade-off for complexity. Instead, do backups. Easy and reliable. Everbody is happy, without many partitions.

Simplicity is crucial and it's one thing the free software ecosystem is consistently getting wrong. I see it as the major showstopper for many people to use it more intensively.

The filesystem hierarchy is just one culprit, but a fundamental one.

Take a look at at some fundamental pure mathematics lectures or books. You can immediately see that this was designed to be as easy as possible. Software must be the same.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by digi_owl on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:24PM (#10361153)
> If my filesystem gets corrupted, I boot into a live cd, just like everybody does.

And that is what makes someone take the road trip to the server farm at 2am because a ge-wiz dev thought the exact same and never considered a "rescue" mode with network capability.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by felixgallo on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:18AM (#10360151)
I boot my rackmount servers in a cage at the dc using a what now?
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by madez on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:08PM (#10360995)
Your use case is a tiny minority which doesn’t provide enough justification to increase the complexity of the default, for complexity being _very_ expensive.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by digi_owl on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:28PM (#10361188)
And this is why Linux user space is going down the tube.

Basically that exact capability is why people adopted Linux in the first place to run the servers that run the net.

I don't see how having a / that can get up and running even when the larger system housed in /usr and such is down for the count, is anything more complex that the piles of VMs and containers that is being advocated today.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by madez on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:52PM (#10361448)
You are free to set up your system as you wish. I also don’t advocate for removing options. I’m asking for a simple default. Simplicity is very important. If you can’t explain what you are doing to your parents, it is not yet simple enough.

Don’t misunderstand simplicity for triviality for they are not the same. We need to make non-trivial problems simple.

Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by spacemanmatt on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:52PM (#10364160)
I run a multiuser shell system for hosting tmux/ssh/irc type usage. It's limiting but it's a labor of love for friends. For anything that matters I use a modern (piles of VMs and containers!) design.
Re:Debian Dropping the Linux Standard Base by felixgallo on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:34PM (#10361827)
Global desktop PC shipments in 2015: ~136mm (http://www.statista.com/topics/1070/pcs/)

Linux desktop penetration: ~1.33% (http://www.netmarketshare.com/operating-system-market-share....)

1.3% * 136mm = 1.77mm

Let's ignore Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Facebook, and so on, each of whom are by themselves rumored or reported to have over a million computers in their DCs. Let's further ignore the long tail of the second tier of providers, who are thousands in number and have merely hundreds of thousands of computers each in their DCs. Let's go on to ignore all of the self serve corporations in the hundreds of thousands of data centers across the world, running Linux or a derivative on thousands to hundreds of computers each.

Let's also ignore all the routers, switches, file servers, and miscellaneous other networking equipment running Linux or a derivative.

Let's further ignore all of the televisions, media players, microwaves, appliances, and other consumer goods running Linux or a derivative.

Let's look only at Android phones, which run an embedded derivative of Linux. The phone market shipped 341.5 million year over year in 2015 Q2 (http://www.idc.com/prodserv/smartphone-os-market-share.jsp). Android had an 82.8% marketshare, so that's 282.77mm.

The number of linux computers that have the ability to boot "a live cd" is 6 thousandths (.6%) of one segment of one part of the linux embedded and server market.

Linux on the desktop has not only been dead for the last 18 years, it's barely a rounding error on a single segment of a single part of the embedded and server market.

By the way, "the complexity of the default" has been fine for over 30 years, and it's still fine. Just because you don't understand it, doesn't mean it's not the right answer.