Re:A Brief History of the End of the Comments
by coldtea on Friday October 09, 2015 @07:18AM
(#10359303)
>My comments were all short, on-topic, and never personal. I provided some sources but generally a different point-of-view than the (until then few) other comments, all right-wing barroom clichés, even celebrations of refugees drowning. None of my comments was cleared, while very vile and unfounded comments continued to pour in.
Make a screen capture video (or a few screenshots) of that happening, post it up on a competitive news site to them, and enjoy their embarrassment and backtracking...
(and help change their bad ways in the process).
In my humble experience, some sites with comment sections also don't want you to engage if you're not on their side. And I think that's more problematic, especially on news sites, because you could get the impression that the comment section was representative of the readers.
Just as an anecdotal example, a couple months ago, I tried engaging in a discussion in the comment section at welt.de, online outlet of one of Germany's largest newspapers.
My comments were all short, on-topic, and never personal. I provided some sources but generally a different point-of-view than the (until then few) other comments, all right-wing barroom clichés, even celebrations of refugees drowning.
None of my comments was cleared, while very vile and unfounded comments continued to pour in.
I tested for a while and experinced the same behaviour on almost all newspaper websites. (On some others, I was immediately attacked personally for my opinion, and that is with moderation in place.)
I since blocked disqus and never looked back. Twitter has been a good alternative for me so far.